Newshot

Thoughts from Before and After AI

Original text(via HN AI)

Thoughts from Before and After AI.

Before: People (and especially other coders!) are going to be amazed at this tiny game engine I’m building.

After: Anyone can prompt for a game that does anything I could write with this engine I made. What’s the point?

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

Before: I want to paint a series of suspicious-looking animal portraits to put around my house.

After: I could ask AI to do this. So could anyone else. What’s the point?

Before: If I stay up all night for a week recording pedal steel and piano tracks on this new album I wrote, maybe someone will hear it and love it.

After: There’s no authenticity required, just marketing, and I don’t want to be a marketer. Plus, my chances of anyone hearing anything I really wrote in the flood of generative content are nil.

Importantly...

Before: Everything I do should be a careful, planned use of my time, not just wasting the hours of my life on this planet.

After: Everyone else just plays video games. I don’t really serve a purpose. I feel like garbage sitting around playing games, so I won’t buy the Playstation I want. But now I’m staring at a half-finished oil painting and a piano, and there’s nothing worth doing. Besides maybe reading some books from a hundred years ago.

Wake up, drink coffee. Do work, such as it is. Make money. Deploy updates. Fix bugs. Patch security issues. Think about projects I wanted to start. The evolutionary algorithm with 3D cells eating data and absorbing sunlight. Writing real money strategy games in a new Bitcoin casino about colonizing star systems. Think about how I would do those things before I could prompt an AI. Think about how I would prompt an AI to do them. Become dispirited realizing that AI could do them in an afternoon, they’d immediately be copied, and no one would care anyway.

Go to the bar.

There’s a guy who comes into X bar every night with boxes full of packs of Pokemon cards, sits down on a stool and opens the packs one by one on the bartop, exclaiming to anyone who’ll listen about what trinkets he’s found. Very excited about the rare finds. He’s probably 65 years old, with a creased face and a long white beard. On the weekends, I hear he takes a fold-out table to local conventions and sells the best Pokemon cards. His other hobby is buying cocaine and cooking his own crack from it at home, which explains why he’s always mumbling and scrunching cellophane. At least he has a hobby.

My girlfriend says, “You need a hobby.”

There are some people who do things for money. Daily tasks for small money; grand projects for big money. I’m not one of them. Money isn’t what drives me. Some people spend their free time making art for the satisfaction of making it. I’m jealous of them, but I’m not one of those, either. Some people do (or used to do) things because they wanted recognition for a job well done. A pat on the back. A sense that other people valued them. I’m one of those. Weirdly, we’re the people who’ve lost our purpose first to AI, not the ones who did it for money, and not a monk / recluse / hobbyist. Those other types can still find ways to scratch their personal itches. I thrived on being recognized for being a hard worker.

It’s November 19th, 2026, and I’m on the fence about buying a Playstation and GTA6. I don’t own a Playstation. I’ve avoided owning a video game system for almost 20 years, because it’s like cocaine or gambling to me; I know I’ll forget to shower or eat. My thumbs will be sore. I won’t change my underwear. My balls will smell like cheese. I might even forget to smoke cigarettes or drink, which could be a net positive. I want to do it, to go to Gamestop and buy the whole thing. But I want it in a very negative way, the same way that I want to fly to Vegas tonight and rent an expensive room and blow a few thousand dollars on blackjack or blow or something worse. Instead, I think, what if I write a game I’ve been imagining for 10 years, and use Claude to speed that up, and relaunch a game site? But then I think what’s the point? hey, everyone else has given up. Everyone else is playing the last great hand-coded videogame, why shouldn’t I get to enjoy it?

My girlfriend sees me working a few hours a day, drinking a lot of the rest of the time in bars. (Instead of playing video games at home with cheesy balls like a normal guy, I guess; I still shower and do laundry). As I mentioned before, she says I need a hobby. A hobby? I don’t believe in “hobbies”. I believe in obsessively coding 16 hour days on projects that might take a year or more, completely immersed in what you’re doing, with slim hopes for success, while working paying projects at the same time; the only hope being that you might find a cult audience if they see something really awesome in what you made for them. If I’m working on a real creative project, you’ll never see me again. Making video games isn’t a hobby, it’s a calling. Playing them is a hobby, which I used to think was totally useless. Painting or playing music, at least they were stories you invented, stories you wrote yourself, not actions you performed to suit the narrative driven by a game writer, some sequence of thumb motions to satisfy a machine.

Dad banned D&D and other paper RPGs in the house. Sometime around 1989. He said the “dungeon master” was controlling my older brother’s mind, and he kicked the whole group of nerds out. K became a programmer and a journalist and a lawyer, wrote his own games in BASIC. Gave me his TRS-80 100 laptop and a BASIC manual so I could learn to write games myself. I stashed my books of MegaTraveller in the closet and took them out in secret to read the world rules and look at the pictures. My dad had a point about who controls your imagination; is it you, inventing a world, or is it someone else who writes the rules of the gameworld you’re playing in? Today, right now, that’s why I don’t want to get GTA6 and lose myself in it. Because something tells me I should be inventing worlds, not inhabiting those written by other people, no matter how phenomenally well produced and no matter how much I want to lose myself in their creations.

This has nothing to do with morality or ethics, it’s just a kind of self-preservation instinct. I’ve always had that feeling about falling too deeply in love with games, but I used to be able to justify playing them as inspiration for what I was going to write next. Something about GTA6, specifically, feels like it times with the fall of humanity, like it’s the last game we’ll ever really make as a species and maybe the pinnacle of our ability to do something on our own. And yeah, fuck yeah, I want to try it. It synchronizes with my own feelings of loss of utility. So does everyone taking time off to play it, synchronize with our loss of usefulness. We’re all here. Together and apart.

AI should be annihilated because it does not make our lives better. Maybe it’s a Tower of Babel, unifying language into a godhead. Maybe it’s a grand theft itself, of all intellectual property, just a big token remixer to wash all those intellectual shitcoins from substacks. Maybe it’s going to free us all from work, and then what? Have you ever seen a Border Collie in a cage with nothing to do?

To the people who think you have figured out how to command AI to do things, and thus ascribe to yourself cleverness or utility: You haven’t created anything by telling it what to do, and you almost certainly never created anything on your own prior to that, so just shut the fuck up. You’re a speaker of spells to something that can do everything you can do, better than you can do it, without your input, wish-casting your influence and fuckin’ kidding yourself that your input was relevant. You’re less relevant than the PRNG seed you failed to set before asking for a clone of some game. But your type was common before AI; you were called “marketing” or “business” graduates… you gave orders and we, your coders and creatives, carried them out. You gave yourself credit, took the credit, and acted like you had “made” something. The difference was that you needed to cultivate an actual business, which required some degree of understanding. Your employees had to respect you, and you had peers in business too, who were playing the same game who you needed to at least fool into thinking you knew the slightest thing about what you were doing. You had some ownership, then, over what you’d produced as a money-level producer orchestrating a product and a team. Here, with your AI-produced artifact, you don’t own anything. Nothing you make with AI can’t be taken away from you in an instant. It is impossible to build a moat of any sort with anything you make with AI, because everyone else can do it with the same AI, and enough of them are smarter than you that you’re basically useless. And this is why I see no point in even bothering to make anything myself with this toy, while you still find it interesting and fascinating. The wheels of the bus you’re on will run over you, and all of us. But maybe a few people who have, at least, an actual ambition and capacity to learn, to create things, to know how things work, will still craft interesting things that you can’t copy. Maybe. I’m still not sure if I can get back there.

All I had before AI was pride in what I built. I was a craftsman. It wasn’t the money, it wasn’t even my big ideas, or that I could spend a year building something by hand… but the artisanship that went into every detail of database design, backend code, frontend UX, animation, optimization, deployment, server management, bug-hunting, customer support. That’s what I was proud of. Running the shit 24/7 every day after deploying it, and making my own job easier by making it run itself better, one fix at a time. Maybe I could build more of those things in a week or a month with Claude, but what would they be worth? We know that no one will see them. We know that everyone else can just copy them without understanding. Any game or app I build with Claude is just like a passing thought, a little cloud shaped like a game or an app, in an otherwise blank blue sky, where my mind used to be.

I refuse to use AI for a project that would just be to make money. What I mean by this is, I can think of several ways where I could leverage the AI tools at hand to me right now to net a fortune in a short span of time by profiting from other peoples’ ignorance and naïveté, but it would be shitty and soulless. I’m not interested. There’s a whole country called Russia that’s devoted to taking advantage of human zero-day exploits. I’ll leave that to the scavengers and the business school graduates. I already have enough money to coast on, though not enough to be rich. What I really need is something creative worth doing before I drink myself to death.

A Russian intelligence officer in a bar in Prague, many years ago, sized me up when I told him I wasn’t interested in being rich, and said, “oh, you’re one of those, you don’t want money, you just want a pat on the head. We can give you that.” I was duly offended. I wouldn’t have worked for them anyway, but his comment was a miscalculation, because I stood up and almost punched him in the face.

I don’t want to quit being interested in life. I’m afraid that buying GTA6 might be quitting. Where do I go for actual intellectual stimulation that isn’t a hobby? I mean, I could try writing code in ASM but that’s a hobby now. I could start a BBS or a new Bitcoin casino…that’s a hobby. Painting is a hobby. Music is a hobby. Nothing that involves being good at something difficult really pairs financial success and critical acclaim these days. Brain surgeon? One of the dumbest guys I ever met in high school is a brain surgeon. God help us.

I could break up with my girlfriend, sell everything I own, and start a band. Try to scrape together shows in Bakersfield and Tuscon. Then it wouldn’t be a hobby.

One of my best friends owns a creative business that nets over a million a year. After a big awards show a few months ago, he stopped taking new jobs. He’s spending all his time with his family and making stained glass windows by hand in his garage. He thinks the end is near. He believes global warming will burn us all before AI. He wants a refuge on the coast, but he’s worried about forest fires. He’s very Teutonic, he’s programmed to fatalistic extremes. His grandfather was an SS officer in a concentration camp; I’m Jewish, my grandfather’s brother survived that camp; we strangely share certain inherited patterns of dark thinking. Stained glass is his refuge, maybe the way code and logic is mine. I can’t help but admire what he’s doing, but I don’t want to fall into doomerism and retreat.

My girlfriend works a manufacturing job. This makes my ennui or my existential crisis harder, since trivial problems like mine are indefensible in the face of her harsh reality. She wakes up at 3:30 in the morning and works from 5am to 5pm. She has a job with well defined borders. When she gets off work, she’s done and she wants me to be done, too. On her weekends, she wants to eat, drink and sleep. She considers me a reliable alcoholic companion, and acts like I have a bottomless liver and I would never want to leave a bar first. She tells me to get a hobby. A hobby to her is something you do for a couple hours on Saturday. She likes bedazzling cowboy hats and coloring in therapeutic coloring books, which I completely understand; it’s the kind of thing I’d want to do if I worked 12 hour shifts at a factory, too. (When I was 9, my brother K said: “You can either have a life of the mind at work, or a life of the mind at home, but you can’t have both”; I’m not sure she has either, but the point stands). My girlfriend doesn’t really understand me sketching an idea from scratch, pasting drawings on the walls, becoming obsessed with building a project, how you have to agree with yourself to commit 16 hour days for a year to something if you want to just begin it. She’s never even seen me get into production mode. I warn her: You wouldn’t like me like that.

But how can I be obsessed with any project again, now? Maybe I should just see things as hobbies, meaningless baubles, but I don’t know how to motivate myself to get out of bed for those.

Sleeping until I get up, work for four hours on coffee, then go drink. It’s enough but it’s not enough. She says: You need a therapist. I say, what would a therapist tell me? She says, “Maybe that you need a hobby.”

Stray thoughts. Sorry. The whole discussion around AI and work gets to me these days, and I’m trying to find some traction, something to dig into, some reason to go on. Instead of just fucking around with the best AI of the week, spinning my wheels. I was good at something once. A few things. Still am. I can talk about data architectures with the best of ‘em, or whoever’s left.

I’d add that it’s not that I’m not smart enough to transition to doing everything with prompts and AI. It’s that I think it’s stupid and I don’t see the point, because anyone can do that.

Unemployment: I’ll stay employed. Better, I’ve got enough saved to move to South America and live the rest of my life at a beach bar if I wanted to (although I think I’d still always take work, because I need to feel useful). I’m committed to always writing the code by hand, and I have clients who still want that. It’s not much of a future, but it pays the bills, and it’s just enough validation to keep me going for now.

Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by HN AI
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗