Newshot

in which loyalties shift during the year of betrayal

Original text(via Lobsters)
Technomancy
Technomancy

in which loyalties shift during the year of betrayal

I'm tired of thinking about large language models. I would rather not spend any amount of time thinking about large language models, and if you're in the software industry in 2026, you probably know the feeling. Depending on how tired you are about it, I honestly wouldn't blame you for just closing the tab in the middle of reading this paragraph. Unfortunately I am sorry to report that, as you probably have guessed, today I am thinking about large language models.

As you are surely aware, there are a lot of problems caused by LLMs.

  • problems for people whose writing is non-consensually used for training
  • problems for people who want to know if what they read online is true
  • problems for people who operate web sites getting DDoSed by scrapers
  • problems for people who want to reduce their reliance on tech megacorps
  • problems for people who are exposed to horrific content all day to train models
  • problems for people whose friends and family members succumb to psychosis
  • problems for people who use software and want it to be stable
  • problems for people who maintain software and need to understand it
  • problems for people who make art
  • problems for people who like to breathe clean air
  • problems for people who need to drink water
  • ...and many others

Over the course of this year we've watched as one project after another ignored these problems, threw away the trust of their users, and embraced the plagiarism machine. Anyone who was paying attention knew that GitHub was going to throw us under the bus, but seeing it happen even with high profile open source projects like Linux, Debian, Vim, and rsync stung. We had expected better, but then we slowly came to realize that the alliances we held for decades were just based on convenience and empty words.

For my entire adult life, I've looked to the Free Software Foundation to provide moral authority around how we approach software. Founded in the 1980s, the FSF and its development arm GNU posit an ethical imperative to build software that preserves a user's right to share that software with others and uses licensing to protect that right. This is often contrasted with the Open Source movement which simply claims that these licenses tend to produce higher quality software without bringing in any moral angle around sharing with others.

building being demolished
building being demolished

I do agree that using these licenses is a good baseline, but I'm becoming more and more convinced that framing the entire struggle of liberatory computing primarily around licensing is a dead end. Licensing is necessary but not sufficient for user empowerment1. There's been plenty written on how the Free Software Foundation's purity spiral has done a great disservice to the users who are stuck with hardware that's not supported by free drivers or stuck on employer-mandated operating systems, and that's all absolutely true. But I'm starting to think that freedom is the wrong lens for this, and we should be focusing on solidarity. Solidarity encompasses freedom, but it doesn't ignore the fundamental interconnectedness of the struggle, and it doesn't glorify individualism.

Compare two pieces of software: Chromium and Ripcord. We all know Chromium; it's the browser that serves as a software manifestation of an advertising company's predatory business model. Basically everyone working regularly on that code is getting paid by an oppressive megacorporation to do so. They have constantly been pushing user-hostile features around surveillance and advertising, most notably with their Manifest v3 which cripples ad blockers. It is released under free licenses which are approved by the FSF. Ripcord2 on the other hand is an alternate client for user-hostile chat systems like Slack and Discord. It offers dramatically lighter resource requirements, improved accessibility, and allows users to avoid the spyware that comes with the official clients for these chat systems. It is a shareware program which lets you use some features without paying but puts other features behind a one-time payment.

One of these programs is anti-user, and the other is pro-user. It's pretty obvious which is which! But if you went by the criteria of the Free Software Foundation, you would get this entirely backwards. This may have seemed like a technicality in the 1980s and 1990s, but now that most software that people interact with regularly is delivered as a service, we can't afford to ignore this any more. The four essential freedoms are not enough, and their myopic focus advocates for individual freedom while enabling systemic oppression.

This point isn't new; you could have said all that in 2022. What's new in the Year of Betrayal is finding out how many maintainers we thought were on Team Liberation are actually on Team Oppression.

The silver lining to all of this has been to gain a clearer view of who actually could be trusted. As we've lost ground and been forced in places into a strategic retreat, certain communities have committed to policies that protect their users from slop. If you contribute to free software projects, there's a certain urgency now that wasn't there two years ago. We thought we could rely on the 64,419 packages available in apt but it turns out to be more like the 250 projects on the Starlight list.

I keep coming back to the point that with these projects the code is not their greatest strength. Their greatest strength is their community who share their knowledge and can help each other. Look around you at the projects you rely on. Which of them have leadership that understands and values that relationship, and which of them are just looking for shortcuts to get to the Hacker News front page? The ones that understand this are the ones that are going to weather the storm.

Get connected. See what you can do to help. But remember: we only lose if we give up.

We know that there is no help for us but from one another, that no hand will save us if we do not reach out our hand. And the hand that you reach out is empty, as mine is. You have nothing. You possess nothing. You own nothing. You are free. All you have is what you are, and what you give.
  • The Dispossessed by Ursula K. Le Guin

I've found several of these projects that are exciting to me right now. AlpineBSD is the first OS I know that makes slop contamination a first-class concern in its packaging. It's a brand new project that isn't ready for daily use yet, but it's based on NetBSD which you can use today and bans on slop in their base repository. Since the tragic sloppification of TIC-80, I've switched back to LÖVE for making games, which is delightful. OpenRsync is building a replacement for the classic file-transfer tool. Servo is building an LLM-free browser that isn't funded by an advertising company. Of course there's GotoSocial which has had a strong anti-fascist and anti-corporate stance from the start.

There's a second category that deserves special mention. When Vim got slopped, it was forked into vim-classic. I'm working with some Emacs developers to prepare for the same thing with Human Emacs though it's not yet clear whether this will be needed. opentmux is a continuation of the classic terminal multiplexer. If you've got a program you love where this has happened, look around for who else is affected by it and see if you can support a fork there too.

We are outnumbered and badly outgunned when it comes to funding; we need all the help we can get. Years ago you may have thought you couldn't do anything to help; that your support wouldn't have made a difference. But in the year of betrayal that is no longer true.

Solidarity forever.

[1] River Seeber has written an excellent article that goes into a little more of the background around the FSF and how it's failed badly in this present moment to act with intersectionality to defend user freedoms.

[2] I should clarify I have not actually used Ripcord; this is not an endorsement so much as an example to make a point. I use wee-slack when unfortunate circumstances require me to participate in Slack chats, and I have been lucky enough to avoid needing to participate in Discord chats so far.

« older | 2026-11-18T07:05:36Z

All posts | Résumé | Projects | Talks | About | Technomancy is © 2004 – 2026 Phil Hagelberg

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by Lobsters
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗