Newshot

AI must be held accountable — value statements won’t protect human dignity

Summary

Nature, Published online: 18 November 2026; doi:10.1038/d41586-026-03717-5 Technology companies can’t be the judges of their own regulatory compliance. Centuries of history explain why.

Original text(via Nature)

There is a striking gap in debates about artificial intelligence. Policy bodies and frontier AI laboratories are borrowing the vocabulary of legal constitutions to guide model development and oversight. However, these statements currently don’t include the institutional safeguards that would make such value commitments work.

In September, the UK Parliament’s Joint Committee on Human Rights published its report on AI regulation. It uses ‘human rights’ more than 100 times in as many pages, but doesn’t discuss which rights should be protected or how. AI firm Anthropic in San Francisco, California, has written a ‘constitution’ for its model Claude. In it, numerous values are listed as the tool’s priorities, including the preservation of user autonomy. Yet some of these values, such as autonomy and well-being, compete with each other, as Anthropic acknowledges. The document does not provide an independent arbiter to adjudicate the conflict, or monitor violations by the AI system.

AI governance requires more than just a declaration. It requires a system of accountability. Specific institutions should constrain the tools’ influence in accordance with specific fundamental values and hold firms accountable to individuals affected by AI transgressions. Lawyers call this constitutionalism.

AI is set to completely transform cybersecurity — here’s how researchers must prepare

As a scholar of constitutional law, I see parallels between the current debate on AI governance and how national constitutions have been crafted, broken, borrowed and fixed.

Countries’ constitutions have distinct underlying priorities affecting their design. These fall roughly into two historical approaches (C. Skach Int. J. Const. Law 7, 175–181; 2009). One takes liberty as its priority: describing what people are free to do and what the state should not do to interfere. The other focuses on human dignity: noting not what individuals may do, but what cannot be done to them, regardless of the circumstances or whether they have consented to it.

Germany’s post-war constitutionalism demonstrates the latter. Its founding document, or basic law, was designed in 1949 to put dignity first and foremost — as both the highest guiding value and a constitutional right, the violation of which is actionable in court. It established an independent federal constitutional court, which citizens can approach directly, that became operational two years later. The choice of this value and the legal institutions to protect it were a response to the atrocities of the Nazi regime, in which people became instruments of state objectives.

Frontier AI companies and policymakers should seriously consider using these features of German constitutionalism. When dignity as a constitutional right is violated — by an AI-generated deepfake or by a chatbot that treats a distressed user as just another interaction — the people affected could petition the court directly, and the perpetrator could be stopped and held accountable.

We need a new ethics for a world of AI agents

Enjoying our latest content? Log in or create an account to continue

  • Access the most recent journalism from Nature's award-winning team
  • Explore the latest features & opinion covering groundbreaking research

Nature 659, 861 (2026)

doi: https://doi.org/10.1038/d41586-026-03717-5

Reprints and permissions

Subjects

  • Machine learning

Latest on:

  • Machine learning
  • Are you a budding science sleuth? Take our plagiarism quiz to test your skills Career Column 18 NOV 26

Are you a budding science sleuth? Take our plagiarism quiz to test your skills

Career Column 18 NOV 26

  • Hypothalamic volume and cell-type changes in ageing and Alzheimer’s disease Article 18 NOV 26

Hypothalamic volume and cell-type changes in ageing and Alzheimer’s disease

Article 18 NOV 26

  • AI wearables could exploit people’s most vulnerable moments Correspondence 17 NOV 26

AI wearables could exploit people’s most vulnerable moments

Correspondence 17 NOV 26

  • The prospect of a ‘super’ El Niño demands better ocean monitoring Correspondence 17 NOV 26

The prospect of a ‘super’ El Niño demands better ocean monitoring

Correspondence 17 NOV 26

  • New US Congress should ‘reimagine’ science — not just return to the past World View 17 NOV 26

New US Congress should ‘reimagine’ science — not just return to the past

World View 17 NOV 26

  • How measuring the state of nature can reverse biodiversity loss Comment 17 NOV 26

How measuring the state of nature can reverse biodiversity loss

Comment 17 NOV 26

  • The origins of scrotal asymmetry News & Views 17 NOV 26

The origins of scrotal asymmetry

News & Views 17 NOV 26

  • Voyager 1 is about to achieve a cosmic first: one ‘light day’ from Earth News 17 NOV 26

Voyager 1 is about to achieve a cosmic first: one ‘light day’ from Earth

News 17 NOV 26

  • Hideki Shirakawa obituary: chemist who showed that plastics can conduct electricity Obituary 11 NOV 26

Hideki Shirakawa obituary: chemist who showed that plastics can conduct electricity

Obituary 11 NOV 26

Jobs

  • 2027 Biology Lecturer job board:https://apply.interfolio.com/56017/positions Wenzhou, Zhejiang (CN) Wenzhou-Kean University

2027 Biology Lecturer

job board:https://apply.interfolio.com/56017/positions

Wenzhou, Zhejiang (CN)

Wenzhou-Kean University

  • 2027 Biology Assistant/Associate Professor job board:https://apply.interfolio.com/56017/positions Wenzhou, Zhejiang (CN) Wenzhou-Kean University

2027 Biology Assistant/Associate Professor

job board:https://apply.interfolio.com/56017/positions

Wenzhou, Zhejiang (CN)

Wenzhou-Kean University

  • Global Leading Talent Recruitment at College of Bio-X, Huazhong Agricultural University Join HZAU's global faculty team to advance research with competitive benefits. Wuhan, Hubei (CN) Huazhong Agricultural University (HZAU)

Global Leading Talent Recruitment at College of Bio-X, Huazhong Agricultural University

Join HZAU's global faculty team to advance research with competitive benefits.

Wuhan, Hubei (CN)

Huazhong Agricultural University (HZAU)

  • Postdoctoral Research Fellow Postdoctoral fellowship in vascular biology at UT Southwestern, studying the endothelial basis of cardiometabolic disease. Dallas, Texas (US) UT Southwestern

Postdoctoral Research Fellow

Postdoctoral fellowship in vascular biology at UT Southwestern, studying the endothelial basis of cardiometabolic disease.

Dallas, Texas (US)

UT Southwestern

  • Tenure-System Associate or Full Professor in Rapid Organismal Change MSU Department of Integrative Biology seeks visionary and accomplished scientists for a tenure-system position Associate or Full Professor. East Lansing, Michigan Michigan State University - Department of Integrative Biology

Tenure-System Associate or Full Professor in Rapid Organismal Change

MSU Department of Integrative Biology seeks visionary and accomplished scientists for a tenure-system position Associate or Full Professor.

East Lansing, Michigan

Michigan State University - Department of Integrative Biology

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by Nature
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗