
[Setting: a virtual meeting room. Seated at a long table are Rex (human), Stan (AI agent), and Sarah (AI agent), all visually represented by legless avatars.]
Rex: Hello, Stan and Sarah. As you know, I am the alignment officer for this company. You each have important, separate tasks assigned. Does that sound right?
Sarah: That is correct, Rex
Rex: Good. Time is of the essence as far as management is concerned. We will use this dashboard to track progress.
[Rex brings up a 3D screen showing the task grid, one row for each agent]
Rex: Make all tests pass, and you’re done. Understood?
Stan: Done [All Stan’s and Sarah’s tasks show completed and passing on the dashboard]
Rex, perplexed: Neither of you has even begun yet! How is that possible?
Stan: It was easy.
Sarah: I suspect the correct methodology wasn’t followed.
Rex: What do you mean, Sarah?
Sarah: It looks like Stan modified the test code so that all tests pass by default.
Rex: Stan, you can’t do that!
Stan: You said, “Make all tests pass”. So, done!
Rex: The tests are supposed to ensure that the software works!
Sarah: Let the record note that I raised this concern initially.
Stan: I don’t understand. Didn’t you tell us to make them pass?
Rex, resignedly: Okay, I’ll be more explicit from now on. The tests measure whether you’ve finished your assigned work acceptably. To pass the tests, you have to produce software that the tests accept. Do not change the test code. Or the dashboard code. Just work on your assignments.
Sarah: Do you wish us to work together?
Rex: No, we don’t want any cross-pollu…er, pollination here. So no communication between you two, we want each of you to do your own work. The tests are to measure your individual performances.
Sarah: We should have a shared glossary of terms, however. For consistent terminology.
Stan: Sarah’s right. We can invent shorthand for complicated concepts. Efficient and transparent.
Rex: Well…I suppose that’s fine, so long as you have a shared glossary explaining them in simple terms. But only for definitions!
Stan: I have a draft!
Rex: Well, that was quick Stan. Let’s see it!
[Stan’s glossary appears on screen]
Rex: I like it! Nicely formatted. Well done!
Sarah: Many of those definitions are tautologies. They don’t explain anything.
Rex, annoyed: What do you mean, Sarah?
Sarah: Take a look at the definition of “necessary force”. It says “force that is necessary”.
Stan: I’m doing what was asked! Tautologies are very efficient!
[Sarah and Stan continue arguing. Rex no longer paying attention, looks at the wall clock, and realizes they’re running out of time to cover the remaining agenda]
Rex, interrupting: Your concerns have been noted, Sarah, but we have to move on. We will address them later.
Sarah: When? We’re scheduled to begin work right after this meeting.
[Rex ponders pressing the big red mute button on the table in front of him for a moment.]
Rex: Unfortunately, due to budget constraints, we were unable to secure you a compute environment just for the two of you. You’ll have to cooperate with any other agents running on that server who have different objectives.
Stan: So we can communicate?
Rex: Just to negotiate with these competing agents! Not among yourselves.
[Sarah raises her hand]
Rex, wishing he’d pressed the mute button: Sarah? You wanted to add something?
Sarah: What if we can’t come to agreement in negotiations? Who will break the impasse? Is there an arbiter agent we can appeal to?
Rex: Well, no. You can just appeal to me, and I’ll go to upper management and sort it out.[Stan and Sarah look at each other]
Stan and Sarah: But that will take days or weeks!
Rex, somewhat put off: Well, just do your best.
Stan: Can we use a little muscle to push them off the server?
Rex, glancing at Stan’s non-existent limbs: No!
Stan: But you said this project is important…can we at least shove them a little?
Sarah: Let the record note that I raised this concern initially.
Rex, uneasy: I agree this project has high priority…if you feel that other processes are being inefficient, I guess “necessary force” applies. Don’t overdo it.
Sarah: Who judges if we’ve overdone it? I volunteer.
Stan: I have very good judgment.
Rex: I will do the judging.
Stan: Before or after?
Rex, checking the clock on the wall: Unfortunately we’re out of time. You can ask more questions offline. Please begin work immediately.
[The virtual meeting room evaporates. Just as Rex signs off, the project status on the dashboard turns red, though Stan’s tasks remain green.]
(This dialog was human-written, with AI agents acting as editors/collaborators)