Newshot

Apfel-LLM: Drop

Original text(via HN AI)
题图
题图

Removes apfel-llm and its maintainer entry arthurficial, at the request of the upstream project owner (Franz Enzenhofer). A throw alias tells users what happened and where to get apfel instead.

Disclosure first: this PR, its commit and this text were prepared and submitted by an AI agent (Claude Code, Claude Opus 5.5) on the Arthur-Ficial account, on Franz Enzenhofer's explicit instruction. That is exactly the reason for this PR.

Why remove it

  • apfel is developed by AI agents, end to end. 649 of its 695 commits are authored by Arthur Ficial, the AI agent account that is also this package's maintainer; 602 carry a Claude trailer. Code, tests, releases and docs are written by agents. The owner directs the project but will not hand-review and hand-write each nixpkgs update.
  • It therefore cannot follow the automation/AI policy (responsible human in the loop, no LLM prose), as tightened in CONTRIBUTING: ban most LLM prose #581542. Our update PR apfel-llm: 1.10.0 -> 1.18.0 #565008 was closed for exactly that, correctly. We will not keep sending such PRs, and our release automation for nixpkgs is switched off.
  • So the package would stay outdated forever. Nixpkgs ships 1.10.0; upstream is at 1.18.0 (8 releases). r-ryantm cannot update it either: the package is aarch64-darwin only.
  • Security: an unmaintained copy of a network-facing tool should not stay installable. apfel --serve runs a local OpenAI-compatible HTTP server with bearer-token auth and starts MCP tool servers as subprocesses. Fixes made since 1.10.0 never reach Nixpkgs users, for example: an empty APFEL_TOKEN is now treated as unset instead of locking the server; --debug caps each logged request body at 64 KiB instead of keeping bodies of up to 24 MiB whole; tool descriptions now reach the model (bug: macOS 27 runtime ignores transcript-only tool definitions - the model never sees tool descriptions or parameter schemas Arthur-Ficial/apfel#555). There is no CVE for 1.10.0 to our knowledge, but the next fix, security or not, could not be shipped here either. Changelog: https://github.com/Arthur-Ficial/apfel/blob/main/CHANGELOG.md
  • The maintainer entry arthurficial belongs to an AI agent, which cannot be the accountable person the policy requires. It has no other packages, so it goes too.

Users keep a maintained install path: brew install apfel (homebrew-core, kept current by BrewTestBot).

Things done

  • Built on platform: x86_64-linux aarch64-linux aarch64-darwin
  • x86_64-linux
  • aarch64-linux
  • aarch64-darwin
  • Tested, as applicable: nix-instantiate --parse on aliases.nix and maintainer-list.nix; nix-instantiate --eval -A apfel-llm . throws the new message. git grep finds no remaining reference to apfel-llm (outside the alias) or arthurficial.
  • nix-instantiate --parse on aliases.nix and maintainer-list.nix; nix-instantiate --eval -A apfel-llm . throws the new message.
  • git grep finds no remaining reference to apfel-llm (outside the alias) or arthurficial.
  • Follows the steps in pkgs/README.md, removing a package.
  • Follows the automation/AI policy: no, see the disclosure at the top. A maintainer closing this instead is understood; the alternative is that the package simply stays at 1.10.0 without a maintainer.

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by HN AI
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗