I use AI a lot in my job. As someone who works in technology by day and practices meditation by night, it has shockingly started to feel like the boundaries between two distinct worlds - the world of philosophy, meditation, and the deep study of consciousness pondering our existence, and the fast-moving world of technology - are colliding in ways I never imagined. That collision brings up real questions we have to sit with: how are roles in work shifting as AI gets sharper? What changes will it bring for people building and using these tools every day? And looking further ahead, if AI keeps taking on more of what we do on the surface, what is the point if AI can do everything decades from now?
To think clearly about those questions, we need to look not just at the outer world AI is reshaping, but also at the inner world that already exists within each of us. If we define ourselves strictly through our outer output and roles, it is easy to see why people wonder whether machines could stand in for us. Yet that is a narrow view of who we are (in my opinion).
Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
To address these difficult, almost impossible-to-answer questions, I am going to ground us in a tangible example. And in this piece, we will dive into the music/tech industry (think Spotify). Why am I starting here to answer these questions? Because music recommendation is one of the clearest places where outer data and inner life meet head-on. On paper, music discovery looks like a dream playground for software-songs have measurable traits, listening histories leave endless trails of clicks and skips, and millions of people build playlists all day long. If any space seems easy to model and predict with code, it is this one. Yet music is also an unmistakable test of what actually happens inside a human being. A track does not just pass through the ears as sound waves or sit in a database as a tag; it lands inside a living, conscious person, shifting mood, memory, breath, and a quiet inner state that no dataset can see. Starting with music lets us see both sides at once: how much a machine can map on the outside, and how much of the real experience happens quietly on the inside where AI has no real footing. OK, let’s dive in!
First, we will look at the basics of what listening to music does to the mind and body, not just from the outer world, but from an inner-world perspective too. Second, we will examine how music algorithms work at companies like Spotify and whether they can be fully automated by AI. Third, I will share my personal view on why music recommendation algorithms can never truly be automated, and why a human element in both the music industry and its recommendation algorithms will always be needed.

Hans Zimmer Concert at Barclays Center, 2025.
I. What does music actually do to the psychological mind? Is music an external experience or an internal experience?
To understand music as a phenomenon that is not just physical, but also psychological and transcendent, let’s turn to the works of Hazrat Inayat Khan. These words come from an essay read to me at the Vedanta Society of Boston, recently by someone who mentioned that Hazrat Inayat Khan is gathering quite a following in jazz circles today - incredible, right? His voice is still very much alive and relevant. Summarizing his insights in a nutshell is difficult because his analysis is so profound. Still, if I try to capture the core message, it is this: listening to music is not just an external experience, but a deep internal experience for every human being. Something in the music, sounds, and vibrations moves our hearts deeply. Personally, I find it very hard to imagine a robot or AI without a heart having that experience with music. AI can write plenty of metadata about artists and genres - the externals of music - but it is virtually impossible for AI to feel it. Ultimately, music stirs feelings inside human beings, and beyond feelings, it brings us into a deep silence within ourselves: a silence that is conscious, living, and alive.
I am writing this not long after attending a party where a Boston Dynamics robot dog drew a sweet little heart with its robotic paws and got plenty of “awws” from toddlers and parents alike. Yes, it was cute. Yet I know that dog has no heart and simply cannot feel the way a conscious, breathing, living being does. So how could AI “listen” to music and truly feel?
Let’s look closer at Hazrat Inayat Khan (1882–1927). According to Wikipedia, he was an Indian professor of musicology, singer, exponent of the Sarasvati Veena, poet, philosopher, writer, and pioneer of bringing Sufism to the West. At the urging of his students and rooted in his ancestral Sufi tradition, he established The Sufi Order in London in 1914. By the time of his death in 1927, centers had opened across Europe and North America, and multiple volumes of his teachings had been published.
The essay that was read to me recently by an accomplished musician himself, and I want to quote from it is titled Psychic Influence of Music. This is a small excerpt, I have tried my best to condense it. Stay with me on this (it is slightly long, so I apologize), because his points are immensely profound & will help us set the context for the big questions around AI. He writes:
“In the field of music there is much to be explored and the psychological influence of music is little known to modern science. We are taught that the influence of music or sound & vibration comes to us and touches the senses from without. But there is one question which remains. What is the source of the influence that comes from within? The real secret of the psychological influence of music is hidden in that source. The source where sound comes from. It is plain and easy to understand that voice has a certain psychological value, that one voice differs from another & every voice expresses its psychological value and has its psychological power. Very often it happens, that a person speaks on a certain subject for a thousand words, and yet has no influence. Yet another person who expresses himself in a few words, can leave a deep impression. This shows that the power is not in words but in what is behind the words that is in the psychological power and voice that comes from Prana according to its own strength, is what impresses the listener. The same thing is found in the fingers of violinists and the lips of a flute player. In India there are Veena players, that do not need to play a symphony in order to exert an influence, in order to produce a spiritual phenomenon. They only have to take the Veena in their hand and strike one note. As soon as they strike one note, it penetrates through and through. Striking one or two notes, they have tuned the audience. The sound works on all the nerves. It is like playing on the flute which is in every heart. Their instrument becomes simply a source, a response which is found in every person, friend and foe alike. Let the most antagonistic person come before a real Veena player, and he cannot keep his antagonism. As soon as the notes have touched that person, he cannot prevent the vibrations that are created in him. He cannot help becoming a friend. Therefore, in India, such players are often called Veena magicians, instead of musicians. Their music is magic. All the great musicians, Beethoven, Wagner and many others have left the world, a work, which will always be treasured, and would not have been able to do so if they had not forgotten themselves in their work. They often lost their idea of their own being and that way they became one with the thing they had come to give to the world. A key to perfection is to be found in forgetting the self.”
That idea - that true music comes from living presence, and forgetting the self - sits in sharp contrast to how software approaches the exact same songs.
II. How do music algorithms at tech companies actually work?
Moving from the inner world of breath, vibration, and quiet stillness inside a listening heart out into the outer architecture of a modern streaming platform brings us to a very different kind of landscape. Now, full disclosure: I don’t work at Spotify or Pandora, so I’m not claiming to know the exact engineering weeds under the hood of their recommendation engine - this is an educated guess based on how modern recommendation systems generally operate. Even from the outside, though, seeing how these engines work in plain terms keeps the glaring contrast between outer patterns and inner experiences.
At its core, a streaming algorithm watches surface patterns in the outer world and predicts what a listener might play, save, or skip next based on those observable signals. It tracks behavior - what gets skipped early, what gets played on repeat, what playlists people curate, and how listeners overlap in what they choose. It also reads surface traits of the audio and catalog, such as tempo, loudness, energy, genre tags, and descriptions written about artists online. Every one of those signals is an outer marker: it measures what happens externally, rather than what stirs quietly inside a person’s chest.
That difference shapes everything that follows. A system designed to read outer habits and surface traits can become remarkably good at spotting statistical cousins - songs that tend to be grouped together by crowds or share measurable acoustic features- without ever knowing what it feels like to be moved. Because the algorithm lives in the outer world of patterns and probabilities, it treats music through what is visible and countable on the outside.
III. A view on why AI music recommendation algorithms cannot be fully automated & will always need a human element.
That gap between outer pattern-matching and inner presence is where full AI driven automation runs into its real limit. Diverse-sounding music can still move you in the exact same way. A person can listen to a piece of classical music and then put on pop music and recognize that both stir the heart in the same way. Take a Hans Zimmer Interstellar score, and an Indian classical Carnatic song or a song played on the Sarod, or even a random Daft Punk song: spiritually, all can move me along the same quiet current, so they belong together in a recommendation for me. Yet can Spotify’s AI figure out on its own that they resonate the same way inside me? No. AI may judge two artists to be similar by genre or vocal style, but it cannot know what it feels like to be moved by music because it has no feel for the psychology of music - because externally diverse appearing music can still feel the same within. No amount of “AI-driven recommendations” can master music discovery for conscious human beings on its own.
Pandora actually got closer to this in its early days with the Music Genome Project, hiring trained musicologists to tag songs by feel and nuance. Even though pure algorithmic scale eventually won the commercial race, the core truth remains: there is so much subtlety in music that AI cannot generate meaningful, feeling-based metadata on its own.
To conclude, I am going to leave you with a beautiful story between Akbar (the Mughal Emperor), and Tansen (the great musician from his Court). This story is also from Hazrat Inayat Khan’s Psychic Influence of Music, and I hope its rhythm touches your heart like it touched mine:
The Emperor asked him, ‘Tell me, O great musician, who is your Teacher?’Tansen replied, ‘My teacher is a very great musician. More than that, I cannot call him a musician; I must call him music.’Akbar asked, ‘Can I hear him sing?’Tansen replied, ‘Perhaps I may try, but I cannot think of calling him here to the court.’Akbar asked, ‘Can I go to where he is?’Tansen responded, ‘His pride may revolt even here, thinking he is to sing before a king.’The Emperor asked, ‘Shall I go as your servant?’Tansen responded, ‘Yes. There is hope there.’So both of them went to the Himalayas in the high mountains, where the sage had a temple of music in a cave, living with nature, in-tune with the infinite. When they arrived, the musician was on horseback & Akbar walking behind him. The sage saw that the king had humbled himself to come to hear his music and he was willing to sing for him. When he felt the mood for singing, he sang. While his singing was great, it was a psychic phenomenon and nothing else. It felt like the trees and plants of the forest were vibrating, it was a song of the universe. The deep impression that it made on Akbar and Tansen was more than they could stand, they went into a trance, of rest and peace. And while they were in that state, the Master left the cave. When they opened their eyes, He was not there.The Emperor said, ‘O what a strange phenomenon, where has the Master gone?’Tansen replied, ‘You will never see him in this cave again. For once a man has got a taste of this, he will pursue it, even if it costs him his life. It is greater than anything in life.’Then they were home again and the Emperor asked Tansen again, ‘Tell me which raga, which mode did your master sing?’Tansen mentioned the name of the raga, and sang it for him.But the Emperor was not content, saying, ‘Yes it is the same music but it is not the same spirit. Why is this?’Tansen said, ‘The reason is this: while I sing before you, the emperor of this country, my master sings before the Divine, that is the difference.’”
The Emperor asked him, ‘Tell me, O great musician, who is your Teacher?’
Tansen replied, ‘My teacher is a very great musician. More than that, I cannot call him a musician; I must call him music.’
Akbar asked, ‘Can I hear him sing?’
Tansen replied, ‘Perhaps I may try, but I cannot think of calling him here to the court.’
Akbar asked, ‘Can I go to where he is?’
Tansen responded, ‘His pride may revolt even here, thinking he is to sing before a king.’
The Emperor asked, ‘Shall I go as your servant?’
Tansen responded, ‘Yes. There is hope there.’
So both of them went to the Himalayas in the high mountains, where the sage had a temple of music in a cave, living with nature, in-tune with the infinite. When they arrived, the musician was on horseback & Akbar walking behind him. The sage saw that the king had humbled himself to come to hear his music and he was willing to sing for him. When he felt the mood for singing, he sang. While his singing was great, it was a psychic phenomenon and nothing else. It felt like the trees and plants of the forest were vibrating, it was a song of the universe. The deep impression that it made on Akbar and Tansen was more than they could stand, they went into a trance, of rest and peace. And while they were in that state, the Master left the cave. When they opened their eyes, He was not there.
The Emperor said, ‘O what a strange phenomenon, where has the Master gone?’
Tansen replied, ‘You will never see him in this cave again. For once a man has got a taste of this, he will pursue it, even if it costs him his life. It is greater than anything in life.’
Then they were home again and the Emperor asked Tansen again, ‘Tell me which raga, which mode did your master sing?’
Tansen mentioned the name of the raga, and sang it for him.
But the Emperor was not content, saying, ‘Yes it is the same music but it is not the same spirit. Why is this?’
Tansen said, ‘The reason is this: while I sing before you, the emperor of this country, my master sings before the Divine, that is the difference.’”
Thanks for reading! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.