Newshot

The pleasure of knowing

Summary

There is an inherent pleasure in knowing things. It might be more expedient to externalize your understanding to others: to other people, or to machines. It might be more productive. In many cases, it will be more realistic to not understand things, but to delegate to others to understand for you. And some things you will not want to understand, or you may want to understand but not want to pay the full cost of understanding (for example, a topic which would require you to invest a lot of study time, but where your actual level of interest isn’t that big). But: in many cases, this abandonment of understanding will lead to less pleasure. It will be like having injected a required number of calories for survival vs. having had an ice cream. Both satisfy a need, but humans prefer to have ice cream. We are in a period of human history where you can be paid to understand things, in some professions even without much ritual or formality. Particularly deep understanding commands a decent sala…

Original text(via LessWrong)

There is an inherent pleasure in knowing things.

It might be more expedient to externalize your understanding to others: to other people, or to machines. It might be more productive. In many cases, it will be more realistic to not understand things, but to delegate to others to understand for you. And some things you will not want to understand, or you may want to understand but not want to pay the full cost of understanding (for example, a topic which would require you to invest a lot of study time, but where your actual level of interest isn’t that big).

But: in many cases, this abandonment of understanding will lead to less pleasure. It will be like having injected a required number of calories for survival vs. having had an ice cream. Both satisfy a need, but humans prefer to have ice cream.

We are in a period of human history where you can be paid to understand things, in some professions even without much ritual or formality. Particularly deep understanding commands a decent salary and respect within your industry.

The times are changing. In some places, it is more economical to pay a machine to provide sufficient output. You might say: well that’s not a problem, there’s no shortage of interesting questions to ask, you can just try to understand other things and get paid for that, but actually no, you cannot. You don’t get to pick the topics that interest you, the same way you don’t pick which food you crave or which person you fall in love with. And moreover, only a small portion of the economy is about being paid to understand, and even within those fields which are almost explicitly about that, there’s a lot that happens that isn’t about you understanding, but is more about producing some output and having partial overlap with a quest to understand.

All that is beside the point. The economy is one thing. Individual experience is another thing. The fact that certain professions have existed and proliferated based on the fact that people in these professions know things – that’s a historical oddity, especially if you take in consideration the proportion of such professionals in the overall working force. It’s a blip in human history that “engineers” exist, and learning and knowing things have been private obsessions without any economic guarantee extended to such individuals, for a long, long time.

I reiterate: there’s a pleasure in learning, and understanding things. When you look at something, and you ask yourself “I wonder how this works”, there’s a sense of unsated curiosity, a sense of directedness at the question, a subjective feeling of annoyance for not knowing. Whatever the economics of having a human understand something vs. giving it to someone in another country to understand vs. giving it to a country that exists only in a data center to understand – the human, some human will always crave this understanding, the same way most humans will crave the ice cream, however more expedient it be for them to simply hook up to an IV that provides all their caloric needs.

This human will look at a question and the question will nag them, the question will bother them, the question will exist in their mind and want to resolve itself. That other people or machines understand the answer to that question plays no role in the life of this person. The fact that someone somewhere understands exactly how and why gravity works does not reduce the curiosity that I posses about gravity. The fact that this is a someone smart also doesn’t change it. The fact that a von Neumann understood physics and mathematics to a degree that I probably never will does not abate my curiosity, and does not sate it. The hunger for knowledge is still there, the thirst for understanding is still there. The fact that a Claude Opus 5.5 knows something or that a Jupiter-brained, Dyson-sphere-wielding machine superintelligence knows something – none of these things play any role in my life, except maybe in me having a vague sense that, if you really need some work output to happen that’s based on that understanding, you have other options besides me. You have other people, or other machines that you could ask, that might give you a better answer. The thirst and consequent pleasure of understanding is about me, it’s about my experience and my desire. It’s not sated the same way that I don’t stop craving ice cream when you tell me that an Olympic athlete, whom I will never best in a physical competition, had ice cream. I didn’t have it, and I still want it.

I feel like I am standing before a looming, future, giant, omniscient deity and my puny little intellectual curiosity is merely the hunger of a small field mouse, trumped by the hunger of a massive combine harvester before it. And yet, when the harvester finishes a field, I myself am no less hungry, and I still climb the flowers and lick the nectar, and eat the berries and seeds, and still I crave the pleasure of knowing.

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by LessWrong
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗