NVIDIA RTX 5090 FE Graphics Card Now Priced Near €7,000 Destroyed After Being Sent for Repair, Platform Only Willing to Refund Original Price of €2,369
IT之家 November 21 news: Reddit user @xw1y posted yesterday that an NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 Founders Edition graphics card he sent in for repair was suspected to have been destroyed or discarded by the repair partner of European retailer Proshop.
According to the user's disclosure, this RTX 5090 Founders Edition 32GB was purchased in February 2025 for €2,369 (IT之家 note: approximately 17,394 yuan at the current exchange rate).
In September 2026, the graphics card began to exhibit issues such as reduced clock speeds and abnormal power consumption readings, but it was still usable before being sent for repair. That month, he sent this RTX 5090 FE to Proshop for repair or replacement.
On November 6, the user informed Proshop in writing that the graphics card must be preserved and not discarded, and prohibited any irreversible operations without his written consent.
On November 16, Proshop called to say that a return or refund was possible. Then on November 20, his girlfriend received a call saying that Proshop's after-sales service partner had already destroyed or discarded the graphics card, while Proshop had not yet confirmed this in writing.

According to the email records disclosed by the user, Proshop received the graphics card on September 23 and transferred it to an external repair workshop on October 9.
After weeks of waiting, Proshop informed the user on November 6 that the graphics card could no longer be repaired or replaced, so the original purchase amount might be refunded.
The user explicitly rejected the refund proposal by email that same day, demanding that the merchant preserve the graphics card and all components, while emphasizing that no irreversible operations should be performed without his written permission. He also requested that the merchant provide the inspection results and fault report from the external repair workshop, but never received a clear answer.
On November 16, Proshop reportedly offered the user two options by phone: return the original graphics card, or refund the purchase amount. However, on November 19, when the user's girlfriend called the merchant again, she was told that the external repair partner had already destroyed or discarded the graphics card. According to the user's account, the staff member who answered the phone also admitted that this should not have happened.

As of now, Proshop has not confirmed in writing that the graphics card has been destroyed or discarded. The user stated that the email sent by the merchant on November 19 only provided a link to the complaint handling process of the Dutch e-commerce industry association Thuiswinkel and requested payment information needed for the refund, without explaining the current whereabouts of the graphics card or providing the inspection report he had requested.
In addition, the refund amount has become another point of dispute. Proshop proposed a refund of €2,369 (approximately 17,394 yuan at the current exchange rate), which is the original purchase price of the graphics card in February 2025. By comparison, some RTX 5090 Founders Edition listings on the market are currently priced at close to €7,000 (approximately 51,396 yuan at the current exchange rate).
Under the EU Directive on Certain Aspects Concerning Contracts for the Sale of Goods (EU 2019/771), when goods purchased by a consumer do not conform to the contract, consumers generally have the right to request free repair or replacement from the seller. Only if repair and replacement are impossible, or would impose disproportionate costs on the seller, may remedies such as refund be used under statutory conditions. Whether repair and replacement constitute disproportionate costs needs to be judged in light of the value of the goods, the severity of the defect, and other specific circumstances.
In addition, discussions on Reddit also focused on why the graphics card was directly destroyed. Some netizens pointed out that even if the graphics card PCB is damaged, components such as the GPU core and GDDR7 memory could theoretically still have recycling value and could be transplanted onto a compatible replacement circuit board. However, whether such repair can be carried out still depends on the specific damage situation.
Some netizens also speculated that the repair party may have kept some high-value components from the graphics card, but there is currently no evidence to confirm this claim. The user stated that he took photos before sending the graphics card out and retained materials such as the purchase invoice and email correspondence, has already filed a complaint with Thuiswinkel, and plans to take legal action later.



- "US e-commerce platform Newegg restocks RTX 5090 graphics cards: starting price $6,599, more than three times the official suggested retail price"
Related Articles
- GPU-Z 2.72.0 released: can identify NVIDIA RTX Spark, RTX 4090 Ti ES, adds AMD multi-GPU hotspot temperature monitoring
- Microsoft partners with NVIDIA to upgrade cloud PC experience: dual 4K 60 fps streams, preview launching in 2027
- NVIDIA launches DGX Spark HPC development kit: four-node cluster, 512GB memory, aimed at scientific research and AI development
- The day after Jensen Huang steps down as NVIDIA CEO, RTX 50 series graphics cards see major price cuts in the Japanese market
- US e-commerce platform Newegg restocks RTX 5090 graphics cards: starting price $6,599, more than three times the official suggested retail price
- Counterpoint: Jensen Huang's departure triggers a pace change in the AI industry, interpretation of six major impacts