
The AI side effects we’re not talking about Cloud Native Denmark November 20th 2026 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Hi 👋 , I’m Marcus Noble! I’m a platform engineer at I run a monthly newsletter - CloudNative.Now I’m a CNCF Ambassador Disclaimer: This talk is my personal opinions and not a reflection of my employer or the CNCF 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
I have a confession to make… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The AI side effects we’re not talking about Cloud Native Denmark November 20th 2026 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The AI side effects we’re now starting to talk about Cloud Native Denmark November 20th 2026 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS NOT about… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS NOT about… • Environmental impact that AI is having on our planet 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS NOT about… • Environmental impact that AI is having on our planet • The questionable (at best) source of training data these models use 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS NOT about… • Environmental impact that AI is having on our planet • The questionable (at best) source of training data these models use • AI Hallucinations 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS NOT about… • Environmental impact that AI is having on our planet • The questionable (at best) source of training data these models use • AI Hallucinations • Security implications of AI My thoughts are with my InfoSec friends lately 😅 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS NOT about… • Environmental impact that AI is having on our planet • The questionable (at best) source of training data these models use • AI Hallucinations • Security implications of AI • The industry being held up by the same companies passing money between each other 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What this talk IS about… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
🫵 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
🫵 You! Me! Our peers! Our successors! 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver • AI has dramatically increased the speed at which code can be generated… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver • AI has dramatically increased the speed at which code can be generated… • …but we still have a bottleneck on merging This is nothing new, just ask maintainers of popular open source projects 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver Let’s take a look at how the role of software engineers is shifting from engineering to approving… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Be handed a PR with +1023 -473 changes 4. Read it all and fully understand the code, right? 😅 5. Merge and hope for the best 🤞 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Be handed a PR with +1023 -473 changes 4. Read it all and fully understand the code, right? 😅 5. Merge and hope for the best 🤞 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social 70%
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Be handed a PR with +1023 -473 changes 4. Read it all and fully understand the code, right? 😅 5. Merge and hope for the best 🤞 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social 30%
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Be handed a PR with +1023 -473 changes 4. Read it all and fully understand the code, right? 😅 5. Merge and hope for the best 🤞 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social 40%
Software Engineer to Software Approver This is something that of 2024. Addy Osmani referred to as “The 70% problem” at the end This 30% of friction meant that AI was good for things like prototyping, MVPs and learning aids rather than critical production code. Fast-forward to today and the current leading models have made this much less of a problem, but it’s not gone entirely! The quality of the code produced has vastly improved but the cognitive burden of understanding it still rests on us mere Software Approvers. 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver “But I trust my AI output! --dangerously-skip-permissions and submit the PR is my go-to!” 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ, auto-approve and raise PR 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Raise a PR with +13023 -4673 changes 4. On to the next task… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ, auto-approve and raise PR 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Raise a PR with +13023 -4673 changes 4. On to the next task… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social 100%
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ, auto-approve and raise PR 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Raise a PR with +13023 -4673 changes 4. On to the next task… 5. Colleague / maintainer reviews PR… 1. Reads the wall of text that is the PR description 2. Spends hours trying to understand the context of the change 3. Identifies areas where it will impact other features 4. Oh gosh is that an SQL injection vulnerability?! In this day and age?! 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver 1. Ask your AI of choice to implement XYZ, auto-approve and raise PR 2. See your terminal come to life with lots of very confident claims 3. Raise a PR with +13023 -4673 changes 4. On to the next task… 5. Colleague / maintainer reviews PR… 1. Reads the wall of text that is the PR description 2. Spends hours trying to understand the context of the change 3. Identifies areas where it will impact other features 4. Oh gosh is that an SQL injection vulnerability?! In this day and age?! Ok, maybe some slight hyperbole 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social 100%
Software Engineer to Software Approver Congratulations! You’ve just promoted someone to a full time Software Approver AI generated code doesn’t remove the labour, it just relocates it down the stream. I think Justin Garrison sums this problem up nicely in their “Your Slop, My Sludge” blog post… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Your experts are drowning. They can’t do the quality work you hired them to do because all the slop flows towards the well of knowledge. Justin Garrison 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Software Engineer to Software Approver Congratulations! You’ve just promoted someone to a full time Software Approver AI generated code doesn’t remove the labour, it just relocates it down the stream. I think Justin Garrison sums this problem up nicely in their “Your Slop, My Sludge” blog post. The Harvard Business Review & the 2025 Stack Overflow Developer Survey on AI also suggest similar issues. 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Skill Decline 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Skill Decline Not REALLY but it shares a lot of similar behaviours. • Your brain is a muscle - if you don’t work it out it weakens • Reading code is not the same as writing code We just don’t seem to retain information as well when we read it compared to when we produce it (this is something known as the Generation Effect) • We’re offloading our thinking to these AI models but we don’t seem to be putting that freed up mental capacity towards more critical thinking. Instead the current (admittedly limited) research suggests it’s causing us to get lazier. 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Higher confidence in GenAI’s ability to perform a task is related to less critical thinking effort. https://dl.acm.org/doi/10.1145/3706598.3713778 The Impact of Generative AI on Critical Thinking: Self-Reported Reductions in Cognitive Effort and Con dence Effects From a Survey of Knowledge Workers fi 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Skill Decline • It’s not just our programming skills that are at risk! • As Adriana Villela highlights in their post From Builder to Architect we’re losing our: • • Troubleshooting skills • Writing skills • Motivation to learn It’s also having an impact on our collaboration skills! • Ideas and features are now planned out with AI • Colleagues aren’t discussing work up front so aren’t building up a shared context 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The conversation that feels slower than prompting alone is doing something the prompt cannot do. Left of the Loop by Simon Schrottner 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The Human Cost 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The Human Cost • • • • Replacing existing staff with AI is just silly (and frankly a horrible thing to do) • Klarna replaced 700 employees with AI - a year later they reversed that decision • A leaked Duolingo memo about going AI-first sparked online controversy and caused the company to walk back the decision Some companies seem to be using AI as an excuse to reduce employee numbers to appease investors Hiring freezes are on the rise as more companies asses if their existing staff can Burnout incoming! do more work with AI Callback to Engineer → Approver “59% [of hiring managers] admit they emphasise AI [for] hiring freezes or layoffs […]” - ResumeTemplates.com 2026 survey of 1,000 US hiring managers 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The Human Cost • Stanford Digital Economy Lab found that employment, in the US, of young workers in AI-heavy industries fell ~19% (fell ~13% the previous year) • The SignalFire State of Tech Talent Report 2026 found hiring of new grads in tech dropped to only 8% at “Big Tech” and 3% at startups - going down year on year! • For the new grads that are being hired there’s an increased bias towards “Elite” universities (e.g. MIT, Harvard) - up 10% since 2022 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
The Human Cost Couple this with the skill decline, lack of motivation to learn and reduced communication within teams and you have a shortage of senior engineers within a generation. 😱 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play • For two decades various organisations have been working hard to drive the cost of learning to code towards 0 • These organisations have made huge strides to make our industry accessible to so many people from all backgrounds 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play • AI coding has thrown away all that hard work! 🗑 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play • AI coding has thrown away all that hard work! • You now either pay, every month, or you are capped heavily on a free tier • No Claude Code / Codex available on free tier Yes, I know there are ways to use it with a free model but new folks aren’t going to know that 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play • AI coding has thrown away all that hard work! • You now either pay, every month, or you are capped heavily on a free tier • • No Claude Code / Codex available on free tier Those from a wealthy background have an advantage 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play • AI coding has thrown away all that hard work! • You now either pay, every month, or you are capped heavily on a free tier • No Claude Code / Codex available on free tier • Those from a wealthy background have an advantage • Self-hosting models requires a large up-front spend on hardware • Good chance these models will eventually run on lower-spec hardware but will it be too late? 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Pay to Play If this was the case when I started learning to code I likely wouldn’t be standing here today 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
So what can we do about this?! All of you, right now 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
🤷 But it’s up to us to figure it out together! I have some ideas… 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What can we do about this? Software Engineer to Software Approver: We’ve heard this in a few talks this conference • Be considerate to those who will be reviewing the change • Make sure you understand the code you’re submitting • Don’t be a “meat proxy” for your AI agent - write the description, explain the reason why you think the change is important, understand the implications of the change, be ready to answer questions • Don’t do drive-by PRs! Start a discussion about a change first - open an issue, talk through your idea on Slack. Maybe there’s a good reason your change doesn’t exist. • Do you even need AI to make the change? Don’t send the bots to fix a typo! 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What can we do about this? Skill Decline • Write some good, old-fashioned, artisanal code from time to time. • Use the AI as a tool when needed, not as a complete replacement for the process. • Communicate with your team - build out proposals, design docs, etc. together • Thankfully, people seem to be becoming aware of this. The Stack Overflow Developer Survey 2026 reports: “6 out of 10 users cite a reason to avoid using AI at work or school, losing job skills is a top concern.” 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What can we do about this? Human Cost • Don’t replace people with AI! • Shopify increased their internship program 10x - great example of what companies can do to change things • Laurie Voss has a proposal for how to hire junior engineers in the age of AI • Quoting Adriana & Josh from yesterday: “Transfer wisdom, not syntax” - help juniors build those problem-solving skills 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
What can we do about this? Pay to Play • As individuals: • Volunteer at, and donate to, organisations and initiatives that are working hard to keep our industry accessible and diverse • As companies: • Sponsor access to AI, fund access for students and learners, sponsor open-source development • Hire juniors and train them • As governments: • Sovereign citizen AI programmes - 🇰🇷 South Korea is currently leading the way with this and their “AI for Everyone” program 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
I call on all of you today to start having more of these conversations! We owe it to our peers and our successors to have the same access we had! 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social
Slides and resources available at: https://go-get.link/cndenmark26 Thoughts, comments and feedback: https://go-get.link/cndenmark26-feedback Thank You! 🐘 @[email protected] | 🌐 MarcusNoble.com | 🦋 @averagemarcus.bsky.social