Article title: Reselling Activation Rights for a Domestic Desktop Operating System to Illegally Profit Over 600,000 Yuan; Infringer Receives Suspended Sentence and a 660,000 Yuan Fine
Body: IT Home, November 20 — The Supreme People's Procuratorate today released typical cases of serving the development of new quality productive forces.
A certain software company in Tianjin (hereinafter referred to as "the Company") is the copyright owner of a certain domestic desktop operating system, which is widely used by government agencies and enterprises and institutions. When selling the aforementioned desktop operating system, the Company explicitly stipulated that it retains the software copyright and grants only a non-exclusive, non-transferable license of use to purchasers; neither agents nor end users have the right to privately transfer or resell system image files or activation rights.
Between 2023 and 2025, Wang Moujun, for the purpose of profit and without obtaining lawful authorization, purchased the software image files and activation rights involved in the case from Luo Mou (handled in a separate case), obtained activation rights that customers had purchased but not yet used from his former employer, and obtained activation rights for the system software by forging authorization documents to defraud the Company's customer service; he then publicly sold the system image files and activation rights through multiple internet platforms, illegally profiting a total of more than 600,000 yuan.
On March 28, 2025, the Binhai Branch of the Tianjin Municipal Public Security Bureau (hereinafter referred to as "Binhai Public Security Branch") opened an investigation after receiving a report from the Company. On August 7, 2025, the Binhai Public Security Branch transferred Wang Moujun to the Binhai New Area Procuratorate for examination and prosecution on suspicion of the crime of copyright infringement. On April 27, 2026, the Binhai New Area Procuratorate transferred the case to the Third Branch of the Tianjin Municipal People's Procuratorate (hereinafter referred to as "Tianjin Procuratorate Third Branch") for examination and prosecution.
According to the introduction, the procuratorial organs focused on the following work:
- First, accurately determining the boundaries of criminal protection of copyright in digital scenarios. In response to the practical difficulties of diverse forms of computer software infringement and blurred boundaries of conduct in the context of the digital economy, they accurately distinguished patterns of infringement based on differences in the types of technological protection measures for copyright. The system software involved in the case falls into two types:
- One is activation-free system software, which is licensed only to specific users and can be automatically activated after installation. After illegally obtaining the activation-free version of the system software, Wang Moujun publicly posted sales information on internet platforms and provided specific purchasers, via USB drives or instant messaging tools, with software image files and activation rights that could be used only once. The essence of the conduct was to make multiple copies of the software and provide copies to specific purchasers, which constitutes reproduction and distribution as stipulated in the Criminal Law.
- The other is system software that is openly downloadable and authorized for use through activation rights. Activation rights are a key technological measure by which the copyright owner controls software authorization and protects the complete copyright. Wang Moujun's sale of activation rights was in essence intentionally circumventing or destroying the technological measures taken by the rights holder to protect the copyright of its work. Wang Moujun's above-mentioned conduct violated the provisions of Item 1 and Item 6 of Article 217 of the Criminal Law, respectively, and constitutes the crime of copyright infringement.
- Second, building an evidence and charge system to accurately determine the amount of the crime. In response to the characteristics of online infringement cases, such as fragmented transactions, scattered transaction records, and difficulty in verifying amounts, the procuratorial organs comprehensively reviewed the evidence in the case, checked transaction records one by one against objective evidence such as bank transaction details, WeChat chat records, and internet platform sales orders, and verified and confirmed them one by one in conjunction with the suspect's confessions, accurately determining the amount of illegal profit in the entire case through "cross-verification of objective data + auxiliary verification by the criminal suspect."
- Third, adhering to the principle of balancing leniency and severity and substantively repairing the damaged legal relationship. In response to Wang Moujun's inadequate understanding of the criminal protection of software copyright and the harmfulness of his conduct, they carried out legal interpretation and reasoning, prompting him to voluntarily plead guilty and accept punishment, fully return the illegal gains during the procuratorial stage, actively compensate the Company 680,000 yuan for economic losses, and obtain forgiveness. They conducted a review of the necessity of detention in accordance with the law and, in light of the above circumstances, changed his compulsory measure to release on bail pending trial.
IT Home has learned that on May 27, 2026, the Tianjin Procuratorate Third Branch instituted a public prosecution against Wang Moujun for the crime of copyright infringement with the Tianjin No. 3 Intermediate People's Court. On August 12 of the same year, the Tianjin No. 3 Intermediate People's Court issued a first-instance judgment, sentencing Wang Moujun to three years' imprisonment for the crime of copyright infringement, suspended for three years, and imposing a fine of 660,000 yuan. The defendant did not appeal, and the judgment has taken effect.