Newshot

Has Claude Really Proven the Riemann Hypothesis? Anthropic Mathematician Only Releases Lean Code, Terence Tao Says Verification Will Take Time

AI summary

On November 20, Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge claimed he and Claude had discovered a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis and its generalization, the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH). Alpöge said that Claude "far surpassed me" as the proof neared completion and that he pointed Claude toward a key research direction, after which Claude proposed a series of mathematical ideas that surprised him. According to Alpöge, the text proof he and Claude generated exceeds 250,000 pages and was not made public due to its length; the public materials consist only of a 4-page explanation and about 17 million lines of Lean formalization code split across 14 compressed archives. 2006 Fields Medalist Terence Tao later offered a preliminary assessment on his personal blog, saying that from a very preliminary analysis the proof appears to draw on modern results in the Langlands program and arithmetic geometry, and that it will take the mathematics community some time to sort through the core ideas and verify correctness. Rutgers mathematics professor Alex Kontorovich said on X that proving the Riemann Hypothesis requires "using everything," which instead made him more confident in the possibili

Translation(model translation, not the source's own text)

Has the Riemann Hypothesis Really Been Proven by Claude? Anthropic Mathematician Only Releases Lean Code, Terence Tao Says Verification Still Takes Time

IT Home, November 21 — On November 20 local time, Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge claimed that, working with Claude, he had discovered a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis and its generalization, the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH).

Alpöge holds a bachelor's degree from Harvard University and a PhD in mathematics from Princeton University, and currently conducts research at Anthropic. In his statement, he said that as the proof neared completion, Claude "far surpassed me," "flying, dancing, and shining near the finish line." He also said that he pointed Claude toward key research directions, after which Claude proposed a series of mathematical ideas that surprised him.

According to Alpöge, the textual proof he and Claude generated exceeds 250,000 pages and was not made public due to its length. The public materials include only a 4-page explanation and Lean formalized code divided into 14 compressed archives, totaling roughly 17 million lines.

Terence Tao, winner of the 2006 Fields Medal, subsequently offered a preliminary assessment on his personal blog. He said that, from a very preliminary analysis, the proof appears to draw on modern research results from the Langlands program and arithmetic geometry, and that it will take the mathematics community some time to sort out the core ideas and verify correctness.

Rutgers University mathematics professor Alex Kontorovich said on X that proving the Riemann Hypothesis requires "using everything," which反而 makes him more confident about the likelihood of success.

IT Home note: Lean is an interactive theorem prover used to translate mathematical proofs into machine-verifiable code. Lean checks logical deductions step by step through a small trusted kernel, but it cannot automatically guarantee that the proposition proved by the formalized code is fully semantically identical to the original mathematical conjecture.

Mathematician Elliot Glazer said after a preliminary check that the mathematical proposition formalized in the Lean files released by Alpöge "is indeed the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis." But he also noted that, in theory, the possibility of a soundness flaw in Lean itself cannot be ruled out, though he estimated that probability to be far below 1%. Prior research records show that some historical versions of Lean 4 had kernel defects that allowed invalid proofs to pass.

An October 2026 report in Science also noted that AI-generated Lean code had weakened the wording of the original English proposition in OpenAI's high-profile proof of the Navier-Stokes problem; Lean verifies only the formalized target the code points to, not the mathematical problem itself at the natural-language level.

In addition, a chat screenshot circulating online, purportedly showing 2026 Fields Medal winner Deng Yu commenting on the matter, shows that in response to a related question he replied, "I won't even look at it until there's at least a 500-page version."

Even if the Lean code compiles and the consistency between the formalized target and the original conjecture is confirmed, there is still a long way to go before recognition by the Clay Mathematics Institute.

Under the institute's rules, a solution to a Millennium Prize Problem must be formally published in a peer-reviewed journal and undergo at least a two-year verification period and general acceptance by the mathematics community before it can enter the prize review process. Personal website statements and code archives do not meet the submission requirements, and the Clay Mathematics Institute does not accept direct submissions. The Riemann Hypothesis was included among the seven Millennium Prize Problems in 2000, with a prize of $1 million (currently about 6.692 million yuan at the current exchange rate).

It is worth mentioning that Anthropic had just listed on Nasdaq on November 19, and Alpöge said that after completing the key work late at night on November 15 into the early hours of November 16, he contacted Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei to ask about the timing of the announcement. He admitted that "the timing is very bad," but said "I really couldn't wait any longer."

In August this year, Anthropic announced that Claude had raised the lower bound on the proportion of zeros on the critical line for a Riemann Hypothesis-related problem from 41.6% to 67.2%, which at the time was still a clear gap away from a complete proof.

  • "AI Cracks the Riemann Hypothesis? Anthropic Mathematician Claims to Have Completed the Proof with Claude"
  • "Unreleased New Model 'Scores a Win,' Anthropic Announces Major Breakthrough by Claude on the Riemann Hypothesis"
  • "After Claude's Attempt on the Riemann Hypothesis: OpenAI Announces 10,000 AI Agents Crack a Millennium Prize Problem in 88 Hours, Terence Tao Both Applauds and Worries"
  • "A Million-Dollar Bounty for a Proof: Why Is This Math Problem So Valuable?"
  • "British 'Mathematical Godfather' Atiyah Dies, Once Claimed to Have Proved the Riemann Hypothesis"

Related Articles

  • Anonymous AI Model Gestalt Tops Contra Frontier Design Leaderboard: Performance Far Exceeds Claude Fable 5.2 and GPT-6.1 Sol, Elo Score Surpasses Human Reference Works
  • AI Cracks the Riemann Hypothesis? Anthropic Mathematician Claims to Have Completed the Proof with Claude
  • Developer Integrates Masahiro Sakurai's Game Development Tutorials into a Skill Usable by Various AI Agents
  • Anthropic IPO Reaches a Record $107.3 Billion, Gray Market Trading Suggests Opening Gain May Exceed 20%
  • Claude Linked Billing Test Launched, Third-Party App AI Usage Can Be "Billed on Demand"
  • Aiming for the Largest IPO in Human History, Issue Price $70–78 per Share: Anthropic Approved for Listing Under the Ticker "ANT"

The translation is machine-generated and individual terms may be off. Nothing is rewritten or cut; the original is authoritative.

Published by IT之家
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗