Newshot

Being close to an AI singularity is not anthropic evidence for the simulation hypothesis

Summary

Here's a line of thinking I've heard about how your proximity to an AI singularity might be evidence for the simulation argument: "Of all people that have ever been, I'm remarkably close to the singularity. I read LessWrong/work at an AI lab/am Elon Musk. If I affect the AI takeoff, I'm plausibly one of the 100,000 most influential conscious entities affecting the future light cone. The fact I find myself so close an AI singularity is evidence I'm being simulated by computations interested in this cosmic hinge point" I think this logic is self undermining. It posits that simulator measure is unevenly distributed, and you have a measure that's large, but not too large. But if simulator measure is uneven, it's going to be dominated by extreme outliers. The number of simulation candidates is enormous, googols of googols, from googols of googols of different types of societies. Anthropic measure would pick out, from googols of googols of candidates, those entities most unfathomably extraor…

Original text(via LessWrong)

Here's a line of thinking I've heard about how your proximity to an AI singularity might be evidence for the simulation argument:

"Of all people that have ever been, I'm remarkably close to the singularity. I read LessWrong/work at an AI lab/am Elon Musk. If I affect the AI takeoff, I'm plausibly one of the 100,000 most influential conscious entities affecting the future light cone. The fact I find myself so close an AI singularity is evidence I'm being simulated by computations interested in this cosmic hinge point"

I think this logic is self undermining.

It posits that simulator measure is unevenly distributed, and you have a measure that's large, but not too large.

But if simulator measure is uneven, it's going to be dominated by extreme outliers. The number of simulation candidates is enormous, googols of googols, from googols of googols of different types of societies. Anthropic measure would pick out, from googols of googols of candidates, those entities most unfathomably extraordinarily selected for anthropic measure hogging. And nobody, not you, not Elon Musk, not Dario Amodei, not a human trying monomaniacally to increase their anthropic measure by any means possible, is unfathomably extraordinarily selected for anthropic measure hogging among all candidates in all societies that simulators might simulate.

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by LessWrong
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗