Newshot

No More Denial: UK Court Rules Government Must Admit It Asked Apple to Build a 'Backdoor'

AI summary

A UK court has ruled that the British government must acknowledge it issued a secret order to Apple demanding access to users' encrypted data, paving the way for a public confrontation between the Home Office and the tech giant over privacy and data security. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the Home Office's request to keep the matter confidential, finding that the government had failed to show that disclosing the Technical Capability Notice sent to Apple would harm national security.

Translation(model translation, not the source's own text)

The Secret Is Out: UK Court Rules Government Must Admit It Asked Apple to "Open a Backdoor"

IT Home, November 19 — According to the UK's Financial Times, a British court has ruled that the UK government must acknowledge that it issued a secret order to 曾向苹 requiring the company to allow the government access to users' encrypted data. The ruling paves the way for a public confrontation between the UK Home Office and the tech giant over privacy and data security.

On Thursday local time, the UK's Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected the Home Office's request to keep the relevant actions confidential. Previously, the UK government sought to force Apple to build an access channel in its systems — which critics call a "backdoor" — to bypass the encryption mechanisms protecting user data.

The tribunal noted that the Home Office failed to demonstrate that disclosing the fact that Apple had received a "Technical Capability Notice" (TCN) would harm national security.

This means that, unlike most cases heard by the Investigatory Powers Tribunal, a substantial portion of the legal challenge brought by Apple and related nonprofit organizations against the UK government can proceed in open court.

The UK nonprofits Privacy International and Liberty, which are participating in the legal action, had previously filed complaints with the Investigatory Powers Tribunal over the secret order issued by the UK government. A legal advocate at Privacy International called the ruling "a major victory for accountability, transparency and cybersecurity."

IT Home notes that in July of this year, Apple again filed a legal challenge against the UK government after receiving a second Technical Capability Notice from the government. A year earlier, the UK government had agreed to withdraw a similar prior demand following a dispute with the US government.

Technical Capability Notices are issued under the UK's Investigatory Powers Act. The Act prohibits any organization that receives such a notice from acknowledging the order's existence or discussing its contents.

Such notices can compel companies to provide UK security services with access to customer data, even when that data is protected by strong encryption, and may require that access be opened up.

However, on Thursday the Investigatory Powers Tribunal noted that the UK government had long maintained a policy of "neither confirming nor denying" (NCND) secret orders, but news of the Technical Capability Notice had already been disclosed by the media. In addition, the UK government had discussed the matter with US officials in Washington. These actions constituted a "significant departure" from the original confidentiality policy.

In its ruling, the tribunal wrote: "These departures from the 'neither confirm nor deny' policy, taken together, mean that anyone with even a passing interest in this topic already knows that the Home Office issued a Technical Capability Notice to Apple."

The tribunal also found that the argument that formally confirming the order's existence at this point would harm national security or provide new information to "malicious actors" now appears unrealistic.

Caroline Wilson Palow, Legal Director at Privacy International, said: "Today's ruling is a major victory for transparency and effective oversight. The government should not use the 'neither confirm nor deny' policy as an impenetrable shield."

Related Articles

  • Former Apple chairman 莱文森 plans to sell 90,000 Apple shares, worth about $31.8 million
  • Apple Support Community to close permanently on November 20, no longer accepting new posts starting today
  • Apple avoided $2.7 billion and $2.6 billion in taxes via Singapore and Ireland in fiscal 2026
  • Apple iOS keyboard revealed to hide a list of about 100,000 sensitive words: prevents iPhone input method from auto-suggesting completions, but users can still type them manually
  • After record revenue, Apple plans to issue $7 billion in bonds, returning to the debt market after a year and a half
  • $158.18 billion! Apple's most profitable quarter in fiscal 2027 revenue expected to grow 10% year-over-year, setting a new single-quarter revenue record

The translation is machine-generated and individual terms may be off. Nothing is rewritten or cut; the original is authoritative.

Published by IT之家
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗