Newshot

Only Talking About Yourself as a Defense Mechanism Against Being Vulnerable

Summary

Something about their conversation seemed odd to me. Then I realized they weren’t, in fact, having a conversation at all. What would happen is the first one would talk about himself for ten minutes or so. Then the other guy would talk about himself for ten minutes. And they alternated in this way, interrupting each other. I sat next to them for two hours, and at no point did either of them ask the other person a question. At one point, one of them mentioned that his brother had died a month before. The other simply went back to speaking about himself. If they had met up simply to read out their Facebook status updates to each other in turn, there would have been absolutely no difference. I felt like everywhere I went, I was surrounded by people who were broadcasting but not receiving. Narcissism, it occurred to me, is a corruption of attention—it’s where your attention becomes turned in only on yourself and your ego. —An excerpt from the book Stolen Focus . Unfortunately, in my opinion…

Original text(via LessWrong)
Something about their conversation seemed odd to me. Then I realized they weren’t, in fact, having a conversation at all. What would happen is the first one would talk about himself for ten minutes or so. Then the other guy would talk about himself for ten minutes. And they alternated in this way, interrupting each other. I sat next to them for two hours, and at no point did either of them ask the other person a question. At one point, one of them mentioned that his brother had died a month before. The other simply went back to speaking about himself. If they had met up simply to read out their Facebook status updates to each other in turn, there would have been absolutely no difference.I felt like everywhere I went, I was surrounded by people who were broadcasting but not receiving. Narcissism, it occurred to me, is a corruption of attention—it’s where your attention becomes turned in only on yourself and your ego.—An excerpt from the book Stolen Focus.

Something about their conversation seemed odd to me. Then I realized they weren’t, in fact, having a conversation at all. What would happen is the first one would talk about himself for ten minutes or so. Then the other guy would talk about himself for ten minutes. And they alternated in this way, interrupting each other. I sat next to them for two hours, and at no point did either of them ask the other person a question. At one point, one of them mentioned that his brother had died a month before. The other simply went back to speaking about himself. If they had met up simply to read out their Facebook status updates to each other in turn, there would have been absolutely no difference.

I felt like everywhere I went, I was surrounded by people who were broadcasting but not receiving. Narcissism, it occurred to me, is a corruption of attention—it’s where your attention becomes turned in only on yourself and your ego.

—An excerpt from the book Stolen Focus.

Unfortunately, in my opinion, this is normal behavior among humans—people love talking about themselves. Even though it’s common, I never feel more lonely in a conversation than when people don’t ask me questions. It feels like they don’t care about me. I feel like a ghost.

When meeting new people, I typically categorize them into three buckets in my mind, with only the third bucket being someone I want in my life long-term.

  • The first type is someone who just talks about themself during a conversation.If I meet this type of person at a party or a coffee shop, they may be incredibly interesting, but it doesn’t mean I want to be their friend. I’ll use my affability and epistemic curiosity to investigate who they are and their life experiences, but if they don’t reciprocate, then I’ll make an excuse and leave.
  • If I meet this type of person at a party or a coffee shop, they may be incredibly interesting, but it doesn’t mean I want to be their friend. I’ll use my affability and epistemic curiosity to investigate who they are and their life experiences, but if they don’t reciprocate, then I’ll make an excuse and leave.
  • The second type is someone who is deeply curious when first meeting me, but once a friendship has been established, they stop asking me questions.I know many people like this. They acquire a ton of initial information to quickly build a mental map of who I am, and then use that as a shortcut instead of continuing to get to know me.I am a deeply complex individual, with an ever-evolving perspective on the world, so when people stop asking me questions, I feel incredibly lonely. If I meet this type of person and they’re initially curious, but then slide into monologue-mode, I’ll request that they ask me more questions. If they do? Great! But if they say that they don’t like asking questions, or initially comply and then go back to just talking about themselves, I slowly wean this type of person out of my life.
  • I know many people like this. They acquire a ton of initial information to quickly build a mental map of who I am, and then use that as a shortcut instead of continuing to get to know me.
  • I am a deeply complex individual, with an ever-evolving perspective on the world, so when people stop asking me questions, I feel incredibly lonely.
  • If I meet this type of person and they’re initially curious, but then slide into monologue-mode, I’ll request that they ask me more questions. If they do? Great! But if they say that they don’t like asking questions, or initially comply and then go back to just talking about themselves, I slowly wean this type of person out of my life.
  • This last type of person I love. They’re the type of person who knows that people are endless mysteries and full of surprises. They employ both epistemic and empathetic curiosity to continually explore who I am, while also mixing in their own stories to create an intersubjective experience between us. This makes me feel deeply seen and heard.

Speaking of which, author David Brooks wrote a book on this subject called How to Know a Person: The Art of Seeing Others Deeply and Being Deeply Seen. He explains why you should keep being curious about others:

A person is a point of view. Every person you meet is a creative artist who takes the events of life and, over time, creates a very personal way of seeing the world.When you are asking a good question, you are adopting a posture of humility. You’re confessing that you don’t know [something] and that you want to learn. You’re also honoring a person. We all like to think that we are so clever that we can imagine what’s going on in another’s mind. But the evidence shows that this doesn’t work. People are just too different from one another, too complicated, too idiosyncratic.The worst kind of questions are the ones that don’t involve a surrender of power, that evaluate: Where did you go to college? What neighborhood do you live in? What do you do? They imply, “I’m about to judge you.”

A person is a point of view. Every person you meet is a creative artist who takes the events of life and, over time, creates a very personal way of seeing the world.

When you are asking a good question, you are adopting a posture of humility. You’re confessing that you don’t know [something] and that you want to learn. You’re also honoring a person. We all like to think that we are so clever that we can imagine what’s going on in another’s mind. But the evidence shows that this doesn’t work. People are just too different from one another, too complicated, too idiosyncratic.

The worst kind of questions are the ones that don’t involve a surrender of power, that evaluate: Where did you go to college? What neighborhood do you live in? What do you do? They imply, “I’m about to judge you.”

There is a low-grade epidemic of narcissism amongst people. They love talking about their own experiences, for usually one of two reasons:

  • If everyone else around you just talks about themselves, then it seems normal.
  • But it can also be a defense mechanism against being vulnerable. How? Because there is a surrender of power in admitting that you don’t know something. This can be injurious to the ego of people who want to always be seen as competent, that they have no flaws, that they already know everything, or that they’re always right—it’s all ego. And asking honest questions from a place of humility destabilizes that self-image of unwavering confidence.

Back in college, when I first started trying to deeply listen to people, it made me feel anxious: I wanted to fill that space with talking about my own life. But the more I practiced listening and tolerating that uncomfortable anxiety, the more I realized that people have unique experiences and perspectives worth exploring.

Intentional listening, combined with good questions, allows you to explore the depths of a person’s life. The best kinds of questions to get to know someone, I’ve found, are open-ended questions like: How did that experience shape you into who you are today? What's something that brings you joy but you don't often talk about? How did that event make you feel?

Each of these questions involves a surrender of power, because they’re open-ended and the receiver can answer them however they would like. When you have the humility to ask these types of questions, and admit that you don’t know everything, people let you into their inner worlds—to me, that’s one of life’s greatest joys.

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by LessWrong
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗