Newshot

Experiment images in top-journal paper questioned as AI-generated; Hunan Provincial Department of Science and Technology conducting parallel misconduct review

AI summary

A nasopharyngeal carcinoma study published in the Journal of Translational Medicine drew online scrutiny after users noted irregularities in its experimental images, data, and author affiliation details—such as a 1 cm scale bar containing 12 tick marks instead of 10—prompting suspicions that the images may have been AI-generated. On November 17, the Hunan Provincial Department of Science and Technology's supervision and integrity office said it had directed the corresponding author's institution, the Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University, to investigate, and that the department would simultaneously verify whether academic misconduct or research procedure problems exist. The hospital's research department said it has opened an investigation.

Translation(model translation, not the source's own text)

Experimental images in top-journal paper questioned as AI-generated; Hunan Provincial Department of Science and Technology conducting concurrent research misconduct review

IT之家 November 18 news: A nasopharyngeal carcinoma research paper published in the Journal of Translational Medicine drew scrutiny from netizens yesterday, with the related topic briefly trending on Weibo.

The paper's experimental images, data, and author affiliation information contain multiple irregularities that do not conform to convention—for example, the 1-centimeter span on a scale bar contains as many as 12 tick marks. As a result, some netizens suspect the relevant images may have been generated by AI.

On November 17, the Supervision and Integrity Division of the Hunan Provincial Department of Science and Technology responded, stating that it has instructed the authors' institution, the Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University, to launch an investigation, and that the department will concurrently verify whether academic misconduct and issues with research procedures exist.

The disputed paper is titled "Ferroptosis inhibition via the ROS-GPX4 axis drives microplastic-induced malignant progression of nasopharyngeal carcinoma" and was published online on December 22, 2025. The corresponding author is listed as "Lin Zhao", and the first-listed author affiliation is the Department of Pathology, Second Xiangya Hospital of Central South University.

The Beijing News noted that the affiliation address on the paper's first page is written as "Changsha, Human" rather than the English spelling of Hunan Province, "Hunan"; the postal code is given as "41001l", with the last character being the letter "l" rather than the digit "1".

The more closely watched concerns appear in the experimental images on pages 10 and 15. The ruler used in the images to indicate sample size contains 12 small divisions within the 1-centimeter mark, whereas a standard ruler has 10 divisions in that interval. This detail, which conflicts with physical common sense, became the main basis for netizens' speculation that the images may have been AI-generated.

In addition, some netizens described the tumor images in the paper as "shrimp-paste-like" and raised questions about some of the experimental data and results, but these claims currently remain within the realm of online discussion and have not been independently verified.

IT之家 note: Journal of Translational Medicine was founded in 2003 and is published by BioMed Central under Springer Nature. Its 2025 impact factor is 9.7, and it is indexed in databases including SCIE, Scopus, and MEDLINE.

Springer Nature's publishing policy explicitly stipulates that AI-generated images are in principle not permitted for publication and are considered only under limited exceptions such as clearly established legal provenance or content directly about AI or based on verifiable scientific data, and they must be explicitly labeled "AI-generated".

The Research Department of the Second Xiangya Hospital responded to The Beijing News on November 17, stating that the hospital has opened an investigation. As of press time, neither Springer Nature's research integrity department nor the paper's corresponding author has replied to media verification emails.

Advertising statement: External redirect links contained in this article (including but not limited to hyperlinks, QR codes, passcodes, and other forms) are used to convey more information and save selection time; the results are for reference only. All IT之家 articles containing external links include this statement.

Related articles

  • Using AI to turn Chinese animation characters into erotic images, 7 "pornographic illustrators" sentenced
  • Japanese KFC uses AI to create product promotional images, drawing scrutiny from netizens
  • Bizarre and off-putting: AI food images take over restaurant menus, leaving consumers with no appetite
  • Hohhot national photography bimonthly contest "AI-generated sanitation worker photo wins first prize" sparks controversy; organizers respond "an investigation is underway"
  • CCTV exposes online shopping AI scam: buyers use AI-generated defect images to commit fraud, demanding sellers "refund only"
  • Bestore apologizes over "peanuts growing on trees" promotional image: erroneous use of AI-generated image

The translation is machine-generated and individual terms may be off. Nothing is rewritten or cut; the original is authoritative.

Published by IT之家
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗