Newshot

The 126,900-yuan "poor man's Defender" has become a "rat dropping" for Chinese cars going overseas

AI summary

On November 12, BAIC's XINGTAN 5X went on sale and its exterior design quickly drew attention from overseas media, with CarNewsChina calling it a "poor man's Defender" and Autoblog dubbing it the "people's Defender." A blogger, Tim Oldland, posted a set of comparison images on X pairing the gray-green XINGTAN 5X with a Land Rover Defender 110, and the post quickly spread overseas, drawing more than 200,000 views and over a thousand likes. The argument should not be reduced to "Chinese cars disgracing themselves again" — the embarrassment belongs to BAIC, which took the shortcut of imitation on a brand-new model even though Chinese automakers have long been capable of original design.

Translation(model translation, not the source's own text)

Article title: The 126,900-yuan "Budget Defender" Has Become the "Rotting Apple" of China's Auto Exports

Body:

The 126,900-yuan "Budget Defender" Has Become the "Rotting Apple" of China's Auto Exports

2026-11-17 11:22

On November 12, after BAIC's XINGTU 5X went on sale, its exterior design quickly drew attention from overseas media.

CarNewsChina, which specializes in covering the Chinese auto market, called it a "Budget Defender," while Autoblog used the phrase "the people's Defender." Blogger Tim Oldland posted a set of comparison images on the social platform X, placing the gray-green XINGTU 5X side by side with a Land Rover Defender 110, with the caption:

Yet another Chinese car blatantly copying the Defender... absurd

The post then spread rapidly overseas, gaining more than 200,000 views and over a thousand likes. After the screenshot was circulated back in China, blogger "Design Youth" reposted it to Weibo and asked in response: "Embarrassing, isn't it?"

Image
Image

First, it must be made clear that this controversy should not be summed up as "Chinese cars have embarrassed themselves again."

BAIC is the one that should be embarrassed, and BAIC is the one that should be criticized. Chinese automakers have long had the ability to do original work, yet BAIC, on a brand-new brand, has once again taken the shortcut of imitation.

Image
Image

Ten years ago, Zotye and Landwind imitated Porsche and Land Rover largely because they had no technology of their own and could only rely on a bluffing shell to scrape by in third- and fourth-tier markets. But by 2026, Chinese automakers have already pushed new energy technology to the global forefront, and BAIC has even equipped the XINGTU 5X with an 800V high-voltage platform, a four-wheel-drive plug-in hybrid system with 0-100 km/h acceleration in 4.3 seconds, and Huawei Qiankun ADS 5 Pro advanced driver assistance.

And yet this mid-to-large SUV, with solid specs and a limited-time starting price of just 126,900 yuan, has been dressed in the shell of a British luxury off-roader at its most conspicuous point.

Image
Image

What is even more absurd is that this "rotting apple" that spoils the whole barrel has the two characters "Beijing" squarely affixed to its front.

The problem is not the "boxy shape"

Over the past two years, boxy models have continued to heat up in China. Straight lines, square bodies, and the externally mounted "small backpack" are all common elements of this style. As a result, such models are indeed prone to visual "sameness" in design.

But the resemblance between the XINGTU 5X and the Land Rover Defender 110 has clearly gone beyond the scope of "category commonality." What it borrows is not the abstract concept of a rugged off-roader, but multiple specific designs from the Defender L663 generation.

Image
Image

For example, the round-in-square headlights, the combination of layered grille and skid plate, the floating roof and blacked-out pillars, the horizontal shoulder line running through the body, as well as the rear styling and taillight layout—all of these designs have counterparts on the XINGTU 5X. Paired with its主打 "Cangling Green" paint, at first glance it really does look the part.

Image
Image

Interestingly, BAIC also stressed in its press release that the XINGTU 5X's daytime running lights "underwent more than 300 design adjustments," and that the side windows were "revised hundreds of times" before finalizing the shape...

My suggestion is: don't whitewash yourselves, it will only make things worse.

It is nothing new for Chinese automakers to be criticized for "lookalike" designs. But this time, BAIC in particular deserves the criticism.

Some brands' lookalikes are simply piles of popular elements—full-width light bars, hidden door handles, minimalist center-console layouts, whatever is hot gets used—ultimately producing a batch of similar-looking cars.

But BAIC? It has the BJ series in hand, with plenty of brand history to draw on. Yet this brand, the one most qualified to tell China's off-road story, chose instead to continue someone else's design legacy.

Imitation can bring traffic, but only traffic

Those familiar with the history of China's smartphone industry may remember the "Big Cola" phone made by former NetEase deputy editor-in-chief Ding Xiuhong, one of the representatives of the early wave of Chinese internet phones.

In 2015, the Big Cola 3 phone launched on JD crowdfunding. At the time, Xiaomi, Meizu, and Huawei were fiercely competing in the thousand-yuan phone market, and Big Cola was gradually being marginalized. To regain attention, the Big Cola 3 replicated the just-released iPhone 6 almost one-to-one.

Look—the rounded metal frame, the rear antenna lines, the raised metal ring around the camera—everywhere there are traces of the iPhone.

Image
Image

The momentary traffic brought Big Cola attention and orders, but it did not turn into long-term competitiveness. As supply chain problems and reputational crises broke out one after another, Big Cola quickly disappeared.

Like Big Cola back then, BAIC's XINGTU also faces a question: how can a new brand lacking a foundation of recognition be quickly seen by consumers?

If it starts from scratch with original design, it not only has to spend real money to make consumers remember this new face, but also has to bear the risk that the new styling will not be accepted by the market. By contrast, directly applying the image of the Land Rover Defender is much easier—the presence and recognizability of a million-yuan luxury car are ready-made, and the new car comes with built-in话题 as soon as it debuts; even criticism and mockery can conveniently turn into exposure.

From short-term feedback, this black-red playbook has indeed worked. The XINGTU 5X not only gained ample visibility, but also secured more than 30,000 orders in just over twenty days of presales.

Image
Image

Let us assume for now that these 30,000 orders are not inflated. Then why, knowing it is an imitation, are some consumers still willing to pay?

This is not hard to understand. When consumers pay, they are never just paying for specs and features; they are also paying for styling and design. Especially for potential buyers of boxy off-roaders, the tall, imposing body and rugged stance are core selling points that drive purchase, and the Land Rover Defender happens to provide a ready-made perfect template.

A decade ago, even if consumers liked this million-yuan luxury car look, they might not have dared to buy it easily. Back then, some knockoff models not only copied the exterior but also had poor mechanical quality. Today, however, China's mature automotive supply chain has underwritten this kind of opportunism. Even automakers with limited capabilities of their own can, through procurement and integration, build a product with decent specs and acceptable experience.

Image
Image

This is originally a dividend brought by industrial progress, but it has also lowered the cost of exterior imitation.

A mature supply chain has smoothed over some of the quality shortcomings of knockoff cars. Consumers no longer have to endure a poor product experience for the sake of a look they like, as they did in the past; automakers, meanwhile, find it easier to treat orders as market recognition, and whether the design is their own becomes less important.

But the fact that some people are willing to pay does not mean automakers should do this.

Imitation can bring traffic, but only traffic. If what consumers remember is merely "that domestic car that looks a lot like the Defender" rather than "XINGTU," then no matter how many orders there are, it is still advertising for the Land Rover Defender.

One person's mistake, everyone pays

If the XINGTU 5X had come from a marginal small manufacturer, it would not matter much and would not deserve a dedicated discussion. But the problem is that BAIC is a large state-owned automotive group, and its choices are easily seen by overseas public opinion as the choices of mainstream Chinese automakers.

On overseas social platforms like X, many netizens do not carefully distinguish between Chinese brands. In European, Australian-New Zealand, and Middle Eastern markets, ordinary consumers may not understand the relationships among BAIC, BYD, NIO, XPeng, and Zeekr.

For many people, these brands often share one common name: Chinese Cars.

Image
Image

Over the past few years, automakers such as Geely, BYD, NIO, and XPeng have continued to invest in design, striving to free Chinese cars from the old "knockoff" image. Thanks to advances in electric drive technology, product experience, and design capability, Chinese new energy vehicles have begun entering more overseas markets, and some models priced at 40,000 to 50,000 euros have gradually attracted local consumers' attention.

This reputation has been accumulated jointly by many brands going global.

Image
Image

They say the internet has no memory. Perhaps before long, overseas netizens will forget the XINGTU 5X, but they may not forget that "Chinese cars copied the Defender once again." The resulting trust cost will ultimately be paid by all Chinese brands together.

Against the backdrop of increasingly strengthened tariff barriers and compliance reviews, Chinese auto exports are already not easy. At this moment, another "Budget Defender" only provides new material for the stereotype that "Chinese automakers disregard intellectual property."

Ten years ago, the Beijing Off-Road BJ80 sparked controversy for being too similar to the Mercedes-Benz G-Class. Years later, BAIC has not bid farewell to this shortcut; instead, it has brought it into the new energy era.

The supply chain can buy hardware, but it cannot buy original design, nor can it build brand identity. The XINGTU 5X has gained attention and orders with a look close to the Land Rover Defender, but the face everyone remembers does not belong to BAIC.

The hood clearly bears the words "Beijing," yet what people see is the Defender. For a long-established automaker to still be using someone else's design as its own facade today—that is the most shameful part.

BAIC should be criticized for this, but Chinese cars should not be humiliated on its behalf.

Recommended Articles

Values written like {{NAME_ab12cd34}} are placeholders for real values. Use them exactly as written, in replies and in tool calls alike: they are filled in with the real values before anything runs. Don't ask to verify them, and don't replace them with examples.

The translation is machine-generated and individual terms may be off. Nothing is rewritten or cut; the original is authoritative.

Published by 爱范儿
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗