Newshot

TDS REVIEW | Hands-on with Bose's wired noise-cancelling earbuds

AI summary

This is TDSStudio's 35th article on sspai, once again debuting across all platforms. We previously reviewed the Feile Hong, and at the time some readers in the comments wondered how it compared with the Bose QC20. Wired noise-cancelling in-ear headphones, before the arrival of the TWS era, were once a ... Read the full article

Translation(model translation, not the source's own text)

Article title: TDS REVIEW | Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds Hands-On

This article is TDS Studio's 35th post on SSPAI, and it is once again a platform-exclusive first release.

We previously reviewed the Reecho Hong, and at the time some readers in the comments were curious about how it compared with the Bose QC20. Wired noise-cancelling in-ear headphones were once a very mainstream form of noise-cancelling headphone before the TWS era arrived. Whether from manufacturers like Sony and Bose, which still have mature noise-cancelling products today, or traditional audio brands like Audio-Technica and AKG, all of them have had products of this kind. The fact that wired noise-cancelling earbuds have not seen many new products launched in a market where miniaturized decoding circuits are extremely common nowadays is, rather, something we find a bit regrettable. This is also one of the reasons we were somewhat skeptical when we saw the news that Bose was going to relaunch products in this form factor—after all, Bose is one of the manufacturers that is actually not that keen on "integration." After the China pricing came out, we bought it at launch, and the result... was mostly a disappointment within expectations.

Packaging & Accessories | Package & Accessories

A very flat packaging design, overall similar to Bose's true wireless series. The included accessories consist of three pairs of ear tips and two sets of ear wings. The ear tips have a very shallow insertion depth and feature a filter mesh at the sound outlet, with a dedicated hard retaining ring where they contact the nozzle.

Design, Fit & Acoustic Structure | Design, Fit & Acoustic Structure

Three colors are available at launch: black with blue accents, white paired with light green, and the "Cool Mint" we have on hand—actually a two-tone mix of dark blue-green and light blue, with the cable portion on the darker side. The whole body is glossy plastic, and build quality poses no major issues; it just looks like a conventional plastic-shell in-ear headphone. The housing volume is moderate, smaller than Bose QC Ultra true wireless products and also more compact than the QC20 as we remember it. The opening area for the noise-cancelling microphones is also smaller than on the QC20, and once fitted properly, it is almost impossible to tell it apart from a traditional USB-C earbud.

The shape of the inner side of the housing is different from the QC20's approach of clearly separating front and rear cavities; it is even more like the current Bose TWS series, with a certain protrusion into the concha and the removal of the fully wrapping shark fin. The Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds choose a combination of a split-type shark fin and shallow-fit ear tips. The replaceable part of the shark fin is only the protruding ear wing, which means that for some users with larger auricles, even the included accessories may make it difficult for the earbud to contact the upper edge of your cymba conchae.

When we later invited other friends to try the fit, we discovered another type of problem—thanks here to Mr. F for his help. The original shark fin's ear wing structure is almost on the same plane as the ear tip and the outer cladding of the front cavity, making it easier for the ear wing to do its job under shallow fit. But after Bose made the ear wing a separate piece on the Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds, its position changed, and combined with the relatively flat front cavity, users with small auricles may experience front-cavity coupling issues that cause the ear wing to sit entirely outside the plane of the auricle, making it hard for it to have any real effect... In short, this is a new problem rarely seen on previous Bose headphones. Aside from these, the earbuds themselves are quite comfortable to wear; unless you have a narrow concha, most people should be able to wear them comfortably and securely for long periods. The housing has some thickness, so lying on your side is not recommended.

The nozzle is of the very short type, but conventional in-ear ear tips can still be attached. It is rated IPX4 splash-resistant, which should be fine for light exercise sweat or light rain scenarios.

ANC, Transparency & Call | ANC, Transparency & Call

The passive isolation of the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds can only be described as average, which is also related to the relatively shallow insertion depth and the housing openings. In our comparison, with good coupling it still leaks a bit more high frequencies than the QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds, but among plug-in shallow-fit earbuds it is fairly good. After turning on active noise cancellation, its suppression of steady low-frequency noise is quite pronounced, even reaching the level of Skyline Level, and there is also some depth in the midrange. Suppression of the lower midrange of vocals is fairly obvious, but the attack of the sound is still retained. Its bandwidth coverage is decent for this price, with no order-of-magnitude gap compared to several excellent mid-priced noise-cancelling TWS models. Compared with the QuietComfort Ultra Earbuds third and fourth generations, you can also get slightly lower ear pressure. On the matter of noise cancellation alone, the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds still live up to the Bose name, and the slight background hiss will in most cases not be an issue.

Regarding wind noise resistance, with ANC on, wind sources from the front and sides will produce some wind noise interference, but the wind noise frequency band is not high, and with your back to the wind source there is almost no such problem.

Transparency mode is something we found rather surprising. Previously, most of Bose's earbud products did not pay much attention to transparency mode, but this wired noise-cancelling earbud offers fairly natural ambient sound reproduction. Although there is still some attenuation at both ends, it is already close to the first-tier level. Moreover, the wearer's own voice does not sound too muffled, and conversations at normal volume are no problem. Wind noise has little effect in transparency mode.

For calls, since the call microphone is located at the splitter, the pickup position is in theory lower than the common inline remote module, but unexpectedly the actual pickup loudness and clarity are still good. However, compared with the EarPods USB-C version that we often use as an example, its tone is somewhat muffled and feels more like it has passed through a compressor, with low dynamics. From the perspective of voice calls, this is actually a good thing, since the voice is "louder."

Overall, every noise-cancellation-related aspect of the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds maintains the consistent strengths of Bose noise-cancelling products, and it is arguably the best all-around performer in the current wired in-ear noise-cancelling category, with transparency mode being especially surprising. However, compared with some flagship noise-cancelling TWS models, it lacks some adaptive capabilities and mode options, and the actual noise-cancelling feel is still some distance from the top new products. Considering the price, if you simply need a wired noise-cancelling option for scenarios like long-haul flights, it is usable, and it saves you some charging hassles compared with the QC20. It can enter the In-Ear Skyline Level of the TDS Noise Cancelling Overall Capability Pyramid, sitting in the lower-middle of this tier.

Control & Driver | Control & Driver

Controls on the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds mainly rely on the three-button inline remote at the splitter. The default layout is a set of volume controls plus a center multifunction button: single press for playback control, double/triple press to skip tracks, long press to switch noise-cancelling modes. The clarity of the voice prompts in the earbuds is fairly good, similar to the company's TWS series. However, note that the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds do not support the Bose app, so there is no way to customize controls or update firmware. One more thing: this cable is not particularly soft, and combined with the plug-in in-ear nature, you will find its stethoscope effect fairly noticeable.

Driver information is completely unknown—classic Bose behavior. In any case, as a USB-C headphone, we can still look at some of its sampling parameters. It supports PCM decoding up to 96kHz / 24bit and microphone input ADC at 48kHz / 16bit, which is a fairly basic configuration among USB-C digital headphones.

Wired noise-cancelling earbuds in the past generally implemented noise cancellation in two ways. The first was to build the noise-cancellation processing circuitry into the phone or player and other devices, with the earbuds themselves carrying noise-cancelling pickup microphones. By adding extra conductors to the analog audio jack, the picked-up audio was sent back to the phone, processed, and then sent back to the earbud drivers. This approach required hardware-level support on both the phone and earbud sides, and the connector also needed to be specialized—for example, Sony's digital noise-cancelling series (MDR-NC31, NC750, etc.) worked this way, using a five-pole 3.5mm audio jack. Naturally, if you wanted to connect such earbuds to other devices, you needed to add an adapter cable.

The other approach was to place both the noise-cancellation processing circuitry and the power supply externally. Before the era of USB-C wired earbuds, the usual solution was to put a module carrying a battery and circuitry on the cable before the 3.5mm plug, so that all processing and power were independent of the phone or player, and the relationship between the earbuds and the phone was the same as with traditional headphones. Examples include the Bose QC20 and Sony MDR-EX750NA. The Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds work in a way fairly similar to the latter, except that with higher integration and lower power consumption today, drawing power from the phone over USB-C is enough to support its noise-cancellation processing and audio decoding.

Sound Description | Sound Description

Based on USB-C drive, original ear tips and ear wings.

Article title: TDS REVIEW | Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds Hands-On

Body: The low-frequency quantity is moderate, with relatively little thickness and fullness, average elasticity, and average sub-bass extension. The attack and decay speed is not particularly fast, retaining a certain amount of residual reverberation. The atmospheric rendering has slightly too much diffuse coloration, and is lacking in richness. The low frequency of the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds is rather diffuse and rather sparse; the upside is that it does not mask the vocals or boom in the head, but the problem is that it has no texture, no energy, and no ambience. Instruments whose fundamental tones sit in the lower-mid region do not exhibit any obvious forwardness.

Midrange: the vocals maintain a certain distance and are not overly in-your-face; the mouth shape is moderate in size, and the refinement is somewhat emphasized in the upper registers, but the lower registers are unstable. The texture and line of the vocals are not rendered particularly well, and in a sense this also counts as having no particular tilt... The thickness is not high, the lines are rather blurred, yet some details stand out unnaturally. The tilt between male and female vocals is not particularly obvious; suitable vocal timbres need to be fairly solid while not over-emphasizing thickness. The timbre has some upper-register processing and sounds thin and piercing, yet it is not optimized for catchiness. The throat position is too high, the breathiness is not abundant, and it sounds rather hollow (finally I've used the adjective "hollow" too). Mouth sounds and the like are somewhat forward, and sibilance is perceptible; it is not smoothed out or suppressed overall. The transparency of the vocal frequency band is average, with audible artificial brightening.

As for instruments, most of them are still in a rather hard-to-assess state; it is hard to speak of any texture, while the lines are in a state of average cohesion with some protrusions. Among string instruments, the violin, guitar, viola, etc. have relatively little thickness, and the amount of bowing and plucking detail is on the low side for this price bracket, with mild protrusion. The cello's body is rather blurred and its proportion in the space is small. The brass section has very weak grandeur, and instruments such as the trumpet that need brightness have a somewhat protruding brightness (but not high thickness). The woodwinds have decent airiness and middling naturalness. The instruments' overtones are rather dry, and their richness also lags behind. Among percussion instruments, the Kick has little presence, the Snare decays somewhat quickly, and the cymbals have relatively high brightness, with mild metallic character and harshness retained.

The overall high-frequency brightness is middling, but there are two rather prominent peaks, making the harshness not insignificant. The extreme high-frequency extension is very average, with the roll-off somewhat early, though not to the point of being too rapid.

The soundstage presentation is where the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds attempt to do something different; you can perceive that most of the midrange imaging is pulled some distance away from the ears, with some distance in both the lateral and depth axes, but it is not sufficiently filled in, and the lateral and depth axes are not fully consistent; combined with slightly diffuse edges, you will feel that this space is rather empty. Combined with a middling sense of "height," what the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds present is a slightly oblate-ellipsoid space. The separation between vocals and instruments is average, and the overall cohesion is not good due to the high-frequency peaks. The resolving ability is very average, and the overall information density in the six-hundred-yuan bracket is completely behind domestic wired earbuds of recent years; even from the very narrow angle of wired USB-C call earbuds, I did not feel that the driver quality is better than the IER-EX15C, CX80S, etc. in all respects, and there is also some unnatural "resolving" protrusion. The dynamics are poor, and the transients are acceptable.

Summary Assessment | Overall Impression

Overall, we believe that the noise cancellation performance of the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds is still acceptable; although it cannot be said to be clearly better than new mid-priced TWS products from phone manufacturers, there is no order-of-magnitude gap, and transparency is generally a bit better, plus the call-capture advantage of wired earbuds—there is nothing to criticize harshly about these things. What we mainly want to complain about is instead the sound and fit, which are the most core aspects of an earphone. We had long expected the sound quality to be poor for the price, but we did not fully anticipate that the tuning would be this bizarre. It seems that the ear wings, which appear to allow freer adjustment, do not achieve better concha compatibility, and the shell shape is also rather unfriendly to users with smaller concha cavae. Unless you specifically need a pair for long-haul flights to avoid battery anxiety and simply dislike over-ear noise-cancelling headphones, the Bose Wired Noise-Cancelling Earbuds are not a product at this price that can make you open your wallet. If it did not have usable noise cancellation, it would even become one of the few cases where we currently give a Grade II rating.

KT MARK of the models involved in this article under the market context at the time:

Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds: III (Average)

Noise Cancellation Overall Capability Pyramid | TDS ANC Pyramid:

Bose Noise Cancelling Wired Earbuds: In-Ear Skyline Level

For the KT MARK scoring mechanism and the conflict-of-interest "non-interference evaluation principle," please search for "TDS Studio Scoring Standards and Content Description V202502," which can be searched directly in mainstream search engines.

KingTsui, TDS Studio.

It's a TDS production.

All content is entirely independently created; please do not plagiarize the content, copy the writing structure, etc. All rights reserved.

Simple, easy-to-use, focused writing software, presented to you by SSPAI 🚀
Perhaps you need a lightweight, portable safety box cutter when unpacking packages 📦

The translation is machine-generated and individual terms may be off. Nothing is rewritten or cut; the original is authoritative.

Published by 少数派
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗