Newshot

Empirical feelings

Summary

I often talk about feelings that I purportedly feel. ’That was fun!’, ‘I’m so glad this happened’, ‘I am overcome by sadness’. But a few years ago, in one of those discussions about transforming the known universe into optimal happiness substrate, it came to my attention that I didn’t really know what I was talking about with things like that. For one thing, I just wasn’t sure I knew what, for instance, anger characteristically felt like (in my defense, I’m usually distracted by some incredibly annoying thing happening whenever I am experiencing it). I could probably recognize anger, and was probably talking about it accurately when I said, ‘I am angry’. But if I tried to imagine anger when I wasn’t angry, I was not sure I got it right, and I didn’t have a good explicit description of it. But aside from that—whether or not I’m on top of what the famous feelings actually feel like—there is a question of whether the feelings I have are basically the ones people usually talk about. Like,…

Original text(via LessWrong)

I often talk about feelings that I purportedly feel. ’That was fun!’, ‘I’m so glad this happened’, ‘I am overcome by sadness’. But a few years ago, in one of those discussions about transforming the known universe into optimal happiness substrate, it came to my attention that I didn’t really know what I was talking about with things like that.

For one thing, I just wasn’t sure I knew what, for instance, anger characteristically felt like (in my defense, I’m usually distracted by some incredibly annoying thing happening whenever I am experiencing it). I could probably recognize anger, and was probably talking about it accurately when I said, ‘I am angry’. But if I tried to imagine anger when I wasn’t angry, I was not sure I got it right, and I didn’t have a good explicit description of it.

But aside from that—whether or not I’m on top of what the famous feelings actually feel like—there is a question of whether the feelings I have are basically the ones people usually talk about. Like, if nobody had ever mentioned any feelings, and I had to notice them myself and figure out introspectively which ones existed, would I come up with the usual list? I kind of doubted it.

So for a few weeks I tried to make a list of feelings as I experienced them, or as I particularly remembered experiencing them at other times, as if I didn’t know the usual list. And to pay attention to what they were actually like.

Below is my very tentative list of recurring clusters of feelings, largely written then (2018), with bits filled in later. It’s possible that the things in a given cluster shouldn’t really be together—I am not confident in my ability to remember feelings when I’m not having them. I also don’t know how to describe what feelings are like, so I have gone for anything that I think maybe evokes the right kind of thing. I wrote most of this last year, and haven’t updated it for the intervening months, or checked to what extent the same exercise now would produce a similar list.

With that said, below are some feeling-like-things that I noted, in rough order of decreasing coherence of my notes (not importance). If I recall, a bunch were from the time, and a bunch were ones I specifically remembered from other times (especially toward the end). I tried to categorize and name them for a bit, but didn’t finish. ‘Xxx’ is what I write when I mean to come back and put something in there, though it looks to me like there are a lot of unmarked places I meant to do something later. For instance, perhaps edit everything into coherent prose. But I’m not going to get around to it I think, and a friend really wanted me to publish it anyway. I did redact some bits.

Game of life response

This is sometimes produced by observing Conway’s game of life, especially at a large scale and very fast. I open my mouth, my breathing is affected, perhaps in gasps, I have goosebumps. Reeling attentiveness.

Listening to music can be physically similar, but I’m not sure that the emotional flavor is the same (I have been very affected by parts of Bizet’s The Pearl Fishers and in particular Au Fond Du Temple Saint, as performed by Jussi Björling). Thinking about them from a distance, I think The Game of Life maybe produces more of a sense of OH. MY. GOD that the explodingness is important to. While the opera is more like oh.. ohhhh.. mmmyy…!!!!.. ...!!! …!!!!… …God!!!!!!!!!!!!, and the sense of resonant sadness and rightness through resolution is important to it.

[Added later: for good effect like this, add Baba O’Riley background music to Game of Life and set timing to match.]

There are a bunch of situations where I open my mouth. I think I mean something by it. It’s hard to put into words what. Sometimes I see orange and green leaves with light shining through them. If they are good ones, I often do some kind of double take and then stand there looking at them with my mouth open. I’m not sure what it feels like, except that the leaves are good and my mouth is open. I think I also open my mouth like this while riding bikes and sometimes jogging and maybe looking at roses, and more so if I take adderall and become overly energetic.

Recently (mysteriously) prompted by looking at a friend dancing in costume while he explained something to me. Some plants—I think maybe ones that conform to a familiar plant image. Some part of cuddling, for instance where you pull the other person against you so your stomachs are pressed together, or twine your legs around each other. Maybe musical tension resolving. Maybe physical warmth. Things are as they should be, warmly and deeply. A sense of resolution or familiarity or fitting. Of something being a match for something else. Of coming together, finally.

(It strikes me that cuddling maybe feels right because it matches the way I deeply want things to be, thus eradicating the distance between a desire and reality. Yet also the two people are a match, and when cuddling they fit together perfectly, eradicating the distance between their bodies. I wonder if this adds to the sense of fitting there.)

Deep beauty Looking at a friend, for instance, and feeling like there is value right there—not just hope of future value, or good implications, but this itself is the good thing. (Them? The whole situation? Some kind of intrinsic-value gel they rubbed on their face in the morning that is now being sucked up by my eyes and into my soul? I don’t know.) It feels at least partly visible with eyes. As if every speck of their being is somehow turning to reveal goodness itself. And while time passes, this thing feels somehow not fleeting. It matters, and time can’t erase it.

My plant and a small fraction of bikes seem to prompt something similar.

It is much better than what I would usually call ‘beauty’, such that in the right situation, I might prefer to look at my friend’s fingernails than the most striking sunset between mountains. It comes with a sense of certainty, rare in my sea of uncertainty about everything.

A sense of not wondering whether beauty is really valuable, or whether it is just a thing I can appreciate and chat about with nothing good involved, because you can see the literal value right there on the surface of the thing.

Thinking of another person, alone: chest overflowing or bubbling or flying and feeling lifted and tight and somewhat overwhelming. Related to experience in 2012, and not to that many other experiences.

Substantiveness

This is one of my favorites, but especially hard to pinpoint or describe. I took a long walk in the sun down into Oakland, and I think there was a lot of this. Something about space and solidness and the atmosphere of the place and my body. The sun’s warmth wasn’t just pleasure on my skin—it painted the depths of the world. At once space and solidness. Like every bit of air would resonate with a long low resonant toll if you could hit it with your gong paddle.

This seems to be about realness somehow. I can also feel it strongly in Minecraft though, if I play the right way—I guess it is not surprising that I can feel like something pretend is real, but somehow it seemed surprising. I think because I implicitly believe that the feeling of reality is coming from the reality.

I’m confused about whether this feeling is nothing at all, the best feeling, entirely imaginary, able to be felt by me at any time, able to be felt by me almost never..

Coming back to myself after being lost in conversation or social flow with hanging out with family, walking outside and being present, seeing myself spatially close to the pavement and trees a few feet away from me.

Also maybe comes with something like substantiveness, or some substantiveness. Thinking of it, it feels like a higher, brighter tone of the same deep, clear, resonant solidity.

Things coming into sharpness and real spacial relation with me, now, and a feeling of familiarity.

Urgh, I’m awake again. My mouth tastes bad. I could walk to the bathroom, but I would have to…do something…ugh… do people ever actually want to do things? Ugh I don’t think… whatever.

The world is like a grimy vase full of withered flowers in a room of dust and forgotten furniture. And if the room and the vase and it all were crushed into the dirt, the same feeble and beautiless sunlight would spill on that grey dirt and rubble, and nothing good could ever be built there.

Weak, lifeless grime focused into a point in the middle of my head. Even the pain of that point is grey green and sickened. I’m too tired and grey to mourn the loss of beauty or to wish or care or fight.

All I can think about is doing this thing. My life is not good.

Pullingness xxx

Movement evocation xxx

Caused by watching an old person buy cards in the pharmacy with some dissonant background music, watching a mother and child in the supermarket, watching YouTube videos of marriage proposals.

It is related to sadness, and usually involves crying, but it is hard to pin down the exact emotional tone. I am always glad of feeling it.

Math movement xxx

I can’t remember this at the moment, but I wrote ‘tears behind my eyes, with reading about math type things? Reading permutation city?’

Song sadness

‘…you have been the one, you have been the one for me’…’I’d be the father of your child, I’d spend a lifetime with you’…’I am a dreamer’, ‘..till the landslide brought me down..’

It used to be that I couldn’t listen to Goodbye my Lover without being overwhelmingly sad for this reason

Maybe related to ‘moved’ but is more distinctly sad.

[moon river scene]

Tears rising when I think of men being men, and my friends being men. “Who looks after men?” The song ‘Deeper Water’ evokes this particularly.

This is again closer to [song sadness] than to e.g. depression.

Slightly burning undoing feeling that runs through my body when I see friend’s picture sometimes and was previously feeling bad, similar with imagining open-spaceness, maybe with listening to opera, the back of my neck and my stomach feeling touched in the right way

A slightly burning, firm, wave moving over me, of enlivening and solidity and perhaps substantiveness or something like return

A fizzy burning and a realness in tension moving through my body, feels good, feels like I will return t o something good, my eyes will clear, the ugh will be burned away

Feeling of something infinitely thin turning into nothingness, the moment disappearing, time having jus started

sleepiness / present experience becoming small and unimportant until it disappears from lack of attention

Aversion knob

Everything being hard to bear / the ‘no/don’t’ being right at the start, pressed up against me. Every idea being suffering, every path unacceptable. Should I cross the street? Aurgh! Ok shall we walk along this side in that…No! It’s so wrong..’

Attention string

My attention having gone to something else now, but me not having followed yet, and I should follow, because I’m attached to this cord that is pulling me there

Return glimpse

The moments of rightness and presence amidst long bad sensations - stillness, concreteness, everything stopping whirling, seeing clearly

Sleepiness / myself not being in my head / my soul having slumped further down in my body, and having to pull it up

Not attending to another person, but not being sure where I am instead

Sleepiness while doing something flow-inducing

Fear about headache caused by straining (fizzy micro-energetic like a non-audible buzzing in my mind, tense chest, disinterest in focusing, like a difficulty focusing my eyes but it is mental)

My experience can be folded away and gone, smallness and stuffiness and in-my-face-ness and not being part of the wide and grounded world or the distance—being in a little, fuzzy, unreal world. When I try to feel those things, a sense of too muchness in my chest, like energy that needs to be held down with the tightness of the world.

In different settings, a sense that something is too much and needs constraints to be comfortable, like pedaling a bike in a really low gear. The desire to be held tightly or tied down to stop it.

Sense that if I do anything or pay attention closely to anything, something bad might happen, so I should remain in a state of upright dissipated attention

Feeling of rightness and connectedness in core toward front of body, regarding friend, some kind of related openness

Having snot on thumb: warm colored solid touch on my thumb, attention on my thumb, frustration, fizziness in my arm, do-a-thing feeling, badness. Physical frustration. Having lain in one place for too long, and having to move, but not. Something like pain in the space around my fingers, and maybe my arm. But not actual pain. Frustration feeling? And my back maybe.

Badness/sinisterness/no-ness or something? It seemed so clear for a moment, as a thing that there often is, but now I don’t remember. Maybe it is the same as the everything being suffering thing

Icky waking, head hurts with something like ickiness, face, behind eyes, maybe if I showered? I cry and it feels like it relieves some of the problem, but is a different thing - as if it is a magical intervention that changes some of the murky grey green into clear blue that runs down my face and yet is still somehow dusty and not worth anything in the long run. A trying.

(‘Crush’?, ’Alliance urge’?) Strong desire to see friend, inclination to talk to him in my head, interest in what he thinks of me, desire to say nice things to him

Obsessive hateful annoyance: editing, vegetarians (someone is wrong on the internet?) I keep saying words. Cutting, spiteful, mocking words that would hurt. It is very hard to derail this monologous urge.

(Penis, party) My brain is doing something, and I don’t know what it is

Music feeling (the game of life thing with the sound of violin feeling)

Seeing nice leaves on the sidewalk

[going down a hill on a bike]

Crying-related feeling of there just being a lot of people affected.

Heightened ocd, barriers in my face, maybe a bit related to snot on my finger - things to be resolved, things tangled and that sense of having broken a mirror across your room - too much caring about little things to do

The feeling of red book

The moments of rightness and presence amidst long bad sensations - stillness, concreteness, everything stopping whirling, seeing clearly, familiarity+Return: where something is suddenly solid and good and stable and right after a time of something else, which might have been hard to see itself, but the return shows it up.

[Social crushedness, sleepy, hard to keep head up]

[blindsided emasculation] Person not responding when I speak, DDR pad not responding when I step on it, winded, helpless, punch in the stomach.

Song sadness [‘…you have been the one, you have been the one for me’…’I’d be the father of your child, I’d spend a lifetime with you’…’I am a dreamer’, ‘..till the landslide brought me down..’]

Stubbed toe. Pain. Red and burning deeply. Threatening to control me.+Vivid and deep bruise

(Thesaurus feeling)This has led me to realize that I really like getting the right wordThat is a nice thing about this blog postIt made me understand better [redacted]

New feeling. Seems related to rightness and realness and passion, having untied a mental knot and undone some blockage of blankness found connection with things that had always been real. And now a wave of red radiance. Smiling. With clear darker depth, resonance, substantiveness in my body inscribed with slight burning of passion and happening. Warm redness. But fear that some warmth coming from me will drop down too far behind my back. And earlier fear that it was so blazing and open from my front that other things would get into my heart, if I didn’t find a way to close it. Some tingling in body. Everything else seems a bit more substantive and in focus and under control and visually well defined and I feel like I am wider than usual somehow, because everything is laid out nicely and open and able to deal with things, in my chest, or something.

Taste of virtue

The feeling of seeing someone really show up and care for someone [people giving us money, ]

The sadness of someone being loving and then their work being thrown away or destroyed or lost (I can’t even write down the examples because this one is too sad)

Mine frustration

On reading an article about how bad the child mortality rate in the US is, that nowhere in it says what the child mortality rate is. reaching, urgency, a bit like physical frustration, a light-colored pressure, similar to a feeling of not wanting someone in a social situation to take something and do s something stupid. I interpret it at the time as, I need to do something quickly and take charge because they are just going ahead and grabbing the social norm and destroying it. A bit like a feeling of control-freakiness. Having something mindlessly moved away from you and wanting to say harrumph and indignantly grab it back, and use whatever social power you have to make them stop, with the feeling that you maybe aren’t strong enough

Emasculation

I don’t [can’t?] do things while e.g. close friend does: gash of electric sky opens in my chest

‘I hate myself’

I am worse at this thing than can possibly be acceptable. I lose.

Mental states

Reasonable self

If my mind moved in my head up and to the left, and I looked out slightly differently, and things were more neutrally-toned but also ok and I was an adult who could of course deal with all things responsibly.

Looking into own eyes

I close my eyes and be present, and there I am with myself.

Mental phenomena that are less like feelings

The feeling of something solid and strong and valuable that doesn’t need to be looked at or experienced necessarily, wrt friend

The feeling of opening a thesaurus “I have arrived”, “life is good”, goodness and richness, a sense of standing on a precipice about to fall into the pleasure, but it not quite happening yet so that the joy of being there is prolonged, I guess compared to something like orgasming. Like being on the brink of an orgasm, and somehow getting to appreciate that edge instead of it instantly disappearing. Maybe you are always seeking some kind of gratification, and it is mostly elusive, and this is like actually catching it for a moment, or knowing that you are about to. Things are actually good, you aren’t just distracting yourself from reality or something with this thesaurusing, life is genuinely great.

Social encumbrance

Being ‘with’ someone

Teamness Deep and abiding thing that means I want a person and wasn’t perturbed by details of our interactions being less clear to me, switch of alliance or same teamness or something that would get switched off sometimes in relationships and scare me,

Misc, but maybe somehow mixed with substantiveness

Feeling of picture of [redacted] as a kid and thinking that he turned into [redacted]

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by LessWrong
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗