Apple to Stand Trial in France in June 2027, Accused of Planned Obsolescence Through Restricting Third-Party iPhone Repairs
IT之家 November 17 news: The French consumer rights organization "Halte à l'Obsolescence Programmée" (HOP) announced on its official website on November 16 that Apple will stand trial in Paris in June 2027 to answer allegations that it obstructed users from repairing iPhones through channels other than officially authorized ones. HOP had filed a lawsuit against Apple over this issue four years earlier.

HOP's central challenge is a little-known Apple technology called "Serialization." Simply put, Apple adds digital identifiers to replacement parts so that an iPhone can automatically recognize them after installation. If the phone detects that a non-Apple part has been installed, it may directly prevent that part from working or restrict some of its functions.
HOP points out that even when new or second-hand genuine Apple parts are used, as long as "the repair operation has not been approved by Apple," it may still be subject to software restrictions or remote connection verification. The organization says that over the past few years, this problem has mainly affected the components most prone to failure, such as screens, batteries, and cameras.
Currently, Apple's official stores charge more than 400 euros to replace the screen on the latest-generation iPhone (IT之家 note: approximately 2,939 yuan at current exchange rates). HOP believes that if Apple stopped imposing serialization restrictions, the average cost of phone repairs would be expected to fall, and users could use their existing devices for longer. The organization also notes that producing a single smartphone requires 200 kilograms of raw materials.
HOP says that some changes have occurred since the lawsuit was originally filed.
According to the organization, in 2022 Apple announced restrictions on parts serialization for new iPhones and began allowing third-party repair providers to validate certain repair operations. Apple also previously told the French newspaper Le Monde that some restrictions had been lifted.
For example, starting in 2024, even if users replace an iPhone screen with a third-party generic part, it will no longer cause the True Tone feature to stop working. This feature automatically adjusts screen colors based on ambient light so that the display adapts to surrounding lighting conditions, avoiding noticeable color deviations in conditions such as fog.
HOP also points out that the EU has taken the lead in regulating such practices through the "Right to Repair Directive." However, the organization also stresses that the practical effect of the relevant regulations remains to be tested over time.
In fact, the EU's "Right to Repair Directive" has prohibited parts serialization since August of this year, but manufacturers are still allowed to apply serialization management to certain parts when there are legitimate reasons such as "reasonable and objective factors, including intellectual property protection." This ambiguous wording leaves manufacturers some room to maneuver to a certain extent.
In addition, there is another restriction worth noting: for many replacement parts affected by parts serialization, the European Commission explicitly states in its relevant Q&A document that the "Ecodesign Regulation" takes precedence over the "Right to Repair Directive." Under the ecodesign rules, manufacturers may limit the provision of parts-unlocking tools to repair service providers formally registered in the relevant EU member state. This means that not all independent repair providers can obtain the relevant tools.
HOP President Laëtitia Vasseur said: "The Paris prosecutor's decision to move forward with a trial sends a strong signal to consumers and serves as a warning to companies that harm the right to repair. If Apple is ultimately convicted of planned obsolescence through obstructing repairs, it will be the first such case in France and globally."
She also said that since 2021, Article L.441-3 of the French Consumer Code has prohibited such practices, and the relevant provisions are intended to protect the environment and consumer rights.
In response to the accusations, Apple firmly denied them in an interview with Le Monde, calling the allegations "unfounded." Apple said: "We firmly believe that the best repair is one that is not needed at all. We will continue to innovate to build the world's best products for our users."
Vasseur has already set her sights on 2027, calling it an important year in the fight against all forms of planned obsolescence. At that time, printer manufacturer Epson will also stand trial in February.
HOP also disclosed that it had filed a lawsuit against Apple as early as 2017, accusing it of slowing down iPhone software performance over time. Following an investigation by France's General Directorate for Competition, Consumer Affairs and Fraud Control, Apple ultimately paid a fine of 25 million euros (approximately 184 million yuan at current exchange rates) through a criminal settlement in 2020. At the time, Apple had not informed iPhone users that software updates could cause device performance to slow down.
Related Articles
- Apple iOS 27.3 Beta tests a soft gradient in the navigation bar, returning to an early Liquid Glass effect
- Report says Apple made an exception to negotiate a long-term DRAM supply agreement with Samsung and has launched final consultations
- 5499 → 4499 yuan: Apple iPad mini (A20 Pro) reduced by 1,000 yuan after national subsidy
- Apple China App Store developer platform adds AIGC compliance entry: existing apps must complete filing information by January 31, 2027
- Apple 2027 new product preview: 18 products including iPhone Duo 2 on the list, first AI glasses expected to debut
- Cuktech to launch new Apple iPhone magnetic power bank product on November 20