Newshot

Nintendo's Pikmin 4: Switch 2 Edition Gets a Metacritic User Score of Just 1.8, Slammed as Not Worth the Money

AI summary

The Switch 2 Edition of Pikmin 4 earned a Metacritic critic score of 83, but its user score sits at just 1.8 out of 10, the lowest in the series. Players say the paid upgrade's Dandori Academy mode reuses too much content and that the game runs noticeably worse.

Translation(model translation, not the source's own text)

Nintendo's Pikmin 4: Switch 2 Edition Gets a Metacritic User Score of Just 1.8, Called Not Worth It

IT Home, November 16 — Nintendo added another entry to its growing lineup of Switch 2 version games on November 12 with Pikmin 4. This upgrade not only adds new features but also attempts to offer more value for the paid upgrade by introducing a new mode based on the original's popular "Dandori Academy" gameplay. However, once player reviews came out, series fans were clearly not impressed, feeling that this upgraded version is not worth the money.

The Switch 2 version of Pikmin 4 received a Metacritic critic score of 83, which is not bad, only a few points below the original game's 87. But player reviews show a completely different result. Currently, the upgraded version has a Metacritic user score of just 1.8, far below other entries in the series, making it the lowest-rated game in the series to date.

It should be noted that Metacritic user scores use a 10-point scale, not a 5-point scale.

The Pikmin series has always been a solid performer among Nintendo's game IPs, enjoying high praise from both critics and players. In fact, before this, all numbered mainline entries had user scores of at least 8.1, and Pikmin 4 itself scored as high as 8.9.

However, the limited new content in this "Dandori Academy" upgraded version has clearly disappointed many fans.

From player comments, the criticism mainly focuses on two aspects: first, the price of the paid upgrade does not match the amount of new content; second, "Dandori Academy," the core selling point of the upgrade, reuses a large amount of content from the original game and does not deliver a genuinely appealing new experience.

One player review giving a score of 0 wrote: "Why spend $10 (IT Home note: about 66.8 yuan at current exchange rates) for a game that runs slower and has recycled levels?" This player also compared the Pikmin 4 upgrade to Pikmin 3 Deluxe, previously released on Nintendo Switch, which added much more new content to the original game.

Another review giving a score of 2 said: "Dandori Academy reuses a lot of content. Half of the maps are taken directly from the original game, and although the other half are somewhat different, the layouts are exactly the same."

In addition, the noticeably slower performance after the upgrade is also a commonly complained-about issue. One player said: "This so-called Pikmin 4 upgrade actually makes the game run noticeably worse, with normal loading times extended from the original 6 seconds to over 30 seconds."

This is not the first time Nintendo has been criticized over paid Switch 2 upgrade versions. Previously released titles such as Super Mario Bros. Wonder, Super Mario Party Jamboree, and Kirby and the Forgotten Land also received Switch 2 versions, priced at $80 (about 534.3 yuan at current exchange rates). Players who already own the original Switch games need to pay extra to get the new content.

These upgraded versions had also been questioned by players over insufficient new content, but compared with the strong backlash sparked by Pikmin 4 this time, the criticism then was much milder.

It is still unclear whether the intense player reaction this time is because the Pikmin 4 upgrade genuinely has too little new content, or because Switch 2 users have grown tired of Nintendo repeatedly releasing paid upgrade plans with limited content and have finally decided to express their dissatisfaction through negative reviews.

Related Articles

  • Nintendo's Pikmin 4: Switch 2 Edition Launches, Priced at HK$379 on the Hong Kong eShop
  • Nintendo Moves to Block Switch 2's First Public Jailbreak Exploit: Game Backups and MOD Modifications Restricted Again
  • Nintendo Switch 2/Switch 1 Consoles Update to 23.5.0 Firmware, Digital Game Gifting Support Coming Next Week
  • Nintendo to Hold New Indie World Showcase Tomorrow, About 15 Minutes Long
  • Nintendo Switch 2 Jailbreak Makes Progress, Deltarune and Blood of the Dawn Resource Packages Leaked
  • Nintendo Switch 2 Software Jailbreak Solution ns2jb Released, Can Modify Mario Kart World

The translation is machine-generated and individual terms may be off. Nothing is rewritten or cut; the original is authoritative.

Published by IT之家
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗