Newshot

I'm Glad That Literary Awards Are Going to AI

Original text(via HN AI)
  • 🐾Eneasz Brodski@EneaszWritesI’m Glad that Lit Awards are Going to AI14 min readIt’s 2015 in the main auditorium of WorldCon. Outside the raging forest fires of the Pacific Northwest have turned the sky into a red Mordor haze. The air filters of the convention center are in overdrive as the winner of tonight’s seventh Hugo Award is about to be announced. Every breath holds for one of Science Fiction Fandom’s greatest moments of reckoning.“The award for Best Related Work goes to……No Award.”Me in 2015 after the Hugo Awards ceremony. One of the winners was gracious enough to let me pose with an actual awarded trophy.A cheer rocks the room. My voice is among them, elated. My date is silent. Then she turns her face into my shoulder and cries softly. I’m confused by her reaction, she was just as upset by the Sad Puppies vandalization as all the rest of us.“It was all just so pointless,” she said later. “There was no good outcome. No matter what happened, we all lost.”In 2015 the Hugo Awards, once among the most prestigious awards in Speculative Fiction1, had been hijacked by a coordinated group with a grudge. They’d packed the ballot with their picks (most of them quite bad). Some categories didn’t have a single nominee that hadn’t been forced on by them. After discussion the fan community converged on “it would be better to vote for No Award over any of these pretenders” as the way to deal with this. But with nearly 6000 ballots cast it was impossible to know if the word had gotten out to everyone, and if everyone was on board. Some people thought it would be better to choose among the options given than leave the award unawarded that year.The first six awards given out in the first six categories that night all had at least one nominee that hadn’t been placed there by the Sad Puppies group. Each award was given to a non-Sad-Puppy nominee. The award for Best Related Work was the first one that didn’t have a single non-Puppy nominee to vote for. It was the test to see if our community was willing to shut out the vandals, or let them have what they wanted. When the words “No Award” rang out the floodgates of relief burst. We may not have an award this year, but at least the bastards wouldn’t have their scalp.I had been writing about this for months in my old blog. I’d read and reviewed all the novels, short stories, and novelettes that year. I’d previously been quoted by the head instigator of the Sad Puppies group. I’d been quoted in File770, the SF community gossip magazine. I cared a lot about these awards. I put significant effort into participating in them and going to the conventions where they were awarded. I was very defensive of efforts to hurt them. This was my community. Don’t come for my friends.That was over a decade ago. Well before AI. Recently “The Serpent in the Grove” won the Commonwealth Short Story Prize despite being entirely written by AI. This was not an AI prize, and there was a scandal. “Where Water Works” won the first Almadía Ventosa-Arrufat International Short Novel Prize and was also written by AI. The top award from the Caine Prize went to a work primarily written by AI.This sort of degradation of literature awards would have angered me ten years ago. Perhaps broken my heart a bit, though I probably wouldn’t admit it. For such blatant slop to pollute something I cared about would’ve killed me. Now I smile every time I see it. Now I want it to keep happening, more and more, until the stink of it chokes out the very Heavens. I’m not proud of this, but I don’t apologize for it. It can only happen to those who deserve it.“Mother is the name for God on the lips and hearts of all children”Let me caveat my next point — I greatly admire my father. Maybe I idolize him. He’s an incredible man who took major risks to smuggle his family out of an authoritarian hellhole (communist Poland) and bring them to a foreign country to make a new life. I owe him so much. Also, he was a man with faults like any other, he was making it up as he went along just like any of us, and he had an infant son literally two decades younger than I am right now.I don’t think he knew that I didn’t have many friends growing up. That was fine2 because I had books. I had a thousand worlds full of the most fantastic places and exciting people. The world around me could suck to a fair degree and I’d just slip into a better world whenever I wanted. My father didn’t have this luxury. He was navigating a world without plot armor, trying to shield me from the worst effects of growing up poor. He didn’t have time to read for pleasure. That’s what kids do, not adults.As I grew older my love of fiction only intensified. Rather than outgrowing fiction, my tastes became more complex and (dare I say) refined. But the books still had space ships or swashbucklers on the covers. The older I got the more disdainful he became. He asked me once what I spent all my time reading, and I showed him, somewhat proudly, one of the more interesting books I was into.“Bajki,” he said, the Polish word for children’s fairytales. He did the thing with his voice that I hated, that he’d been doing since soon after I hit puberty, which said “it’s not even worth my time to engage with you.” He asked what I was doing with these child’s stories. I told him I was going to write. I would make something like this. He let his contempt, his disappointment that this was what his son was aspiring to, show openly.They say spite is the best motivator. My dad didn’t know about the Hugo or Nebula awards. He didn’t know there was an entire world of prestigious science fiction read by Serious People who use it to think and discourse. I knew that if I told him about it he’d dismiss them too, wouldn’t even bother looking into what was being done in speculative fiction to interrogate the world and our place within existence as fallen humans. There was no argument that a fourteen-year-old reading SF could make that he would listen to. But I did know that if I grew up and I came home with an award, or better yet, if I flew him out to the awards ceremony and made him sit there and watch as respected professionals celebrated and awarded me personally with a trophy and a title that would follow me for the rest of my life, he would be forced to say that I was right. I wanted to win the most prestigious award I could so I could rub it in his smug, stupid face. To show I was respected and deserved his respect as well. Maybe even his admiration.Why We WriteI don’t start writing until my 30s. Writing doesn’t really pay money, with a handful of extremely notable exceptions. People do not write for money. They write because they love to write, and they are fed by the recognition of their peers. To a first approximation it’s correct to say that authors are motivated by prestige rather than money.By the time I started writing I’d happily established a toehold in the SF Lit world. I’m in a reading group with fellow local authors who enjoy my takes. I’m in a writers group that includes currently professional authors, has Hugo award winners as alumni, and they are impressed with many of my efforts. I helped run the Literary Track of Denver Comic Con, I had dinner with award winners. I have a group of other hopeful up-comers I’m tight with.The literary scene has always been pretty leftist. The scifi lit scene is several degrees more leftist than that. SF lit had always prided itself on being ahead of the curve on civil rights, religious tolerance, sexual freedom, women’s lib, gay rights, etc. The scene leaned hard into wokism from the first moments it shrieked itself into existence. Which I thought was good because I was also quite left. If one award nominee slot every year went to advocacy that was fine.3 Maybe even good.In February of 2015 my first short story was published in Asimov’s magazine. (It was later shortlisted for the 2015 Sidewise Award). That same month K. Tempest Bradford (established editor and thought leader) pushed for everyone to stop reading white men for a year.The official article in TIME magazine is toned down. I was in the audience when she argued for this during a panel discussion at the convention where the Hugo Awards are given out. The argument was quite direct when she spoke freely. My community erupted into discourse not about if this was an acceptable thing to propose, but about how much one should eliminate white men from the SF community. Should we stop reading them for a year, or only a few weeks? Is it OK to read those who are pre-vetted by trusted editors? Can one save the works of favorite authors to read after the embargo? Maybe we should just not read any by default, but if a piece is known to be really good and it happens to be by a white man it’s OK to read it? Didn’t white men deserve this? Couldn’t they take one measly year of no readers? We all know this won’t happen anyway, haha, so what does it say about someone if they feel threatened by it?The fact is, white men were still being published, and read, and respected in the community. So saying “I feel this would hurt me” would be an acknowledgement that one believes that their work isn’t good enough to stand on its own. Every year some new white men get their first publishing contract in the SF world, despite being white men. Every now and then they’ll have a hit, just like anyone else. If you can’t get published, if you never make it big, well, you obviously just didn’t have the talent needed to make it. Happens to 99% of people who try. There is no way to say “this is fucked up” without being seen as another no-talent white male blaming his problems on minorities and women. All you can do is keep your head down, keep writing with everything you have, and trust that the crazies will be ignored and you’ll be treated fairly. Everyone is basically good.We rally to rebuff the Sad Puppies as a united community, and it feels good.I Get The HintI keep writing. I get published in Analog magazine as well, and several anthologies, and win a Writers of the Future award. But it’s getting harder to be in this community. More and more works that are celebrated seem bad. It’s not random either, it’s not just very personable authors getting love from their fans/friends, as the Sad Puppies had complained about — now the badness is strongly correlated with activism. After a few years the only men left in the major awards are those who’ve led woke charges.My favorite author, N.K. Jemisin, who I hope to some day write half as well as, weighs in strongly in favor of my demographic being removed from SF lit. This really hurts. I had idolized her.I notice a lot of men authors are adopting They/Them pronouns. Eventually even the “ally” men are removed. The book club I was in reads the Hugo Nominated novels, short stories, and novelettes every year. More and more in the later years I was reading straight racist/sexist diatribes against me, which were being praised by my peers. I’m told you can’t be racist against white men. What, they can’t take it? In the years 2019-2021 no white men appear in the best novel short lists at all (in 2022 Andy Weir breaks this with Project Hail Mary. That is the level of success needed to be considered for a Hugo then.)I realize I haven’t enjoyed most of what I’ve been reading for years.The final blow comes in 2020. It’s the second year of the awards lockout. “A Memory Called Empire” wins the Hugo. When I first reviewed it I said“there is nothing exceptional about this. It’s…. fine. It’s fine. But it’s not good. It’s certainly not genre-defining or among the best things published that year. […]I know there’s at least one Hugo nominated novel that I just don’t get every year, but I don’t think anyone is doing Martine a favor by pretending they think her novel is a Hugo contender. I feel bad that this happened.”Upon its winning I wroteI can no longer say anything is “Hugo material” or not, because my judgements of quality do not mesh with the audience of the Hugos. […] I gotta go looking for a community that is more like meLater that same year “The City We Became” is published. By N.K. Jemisin, the author that just a few years ago wrote one of the best works I’ve read. Her new novel is one of the most racist things I’ve ever read4.every white person in this story is a monsterit is explicitly their whiteness that makes them monstrous, and makes them want to destroy and exploit all that is good in the world.one can tell when a new antagonist or ally is being introduced as soon as their skin color is describedhairstyles that are popular among young white men are called literal signifiers of evil - it’s presented as bitterly ironic that now such a signifier exists in real life when before it was just the sign of campy script writers.The one attempt to portray a white person in a “sympathetic” light focuses on a mentally handicapped white woman … Nonetheless, she ultimately gives in to her hateful white natureStaten Island is ejected from what is the True New York City and replaced with a borough that has the correct racial demographics for a “good” city.It’s nominated for a Hugo.And I finally get the hint. The SF Lit world has been telling me very plainly and very loudly for years that they don’t want me. I can write all I want and I will never know if my words are good or not, because they won’t be read regardless.I know a few people who write purely for themselves, who don’t even publish what they write. I am not one of them. I don’t want to shout into the void. I want to be seen. To know that no one will read me drains so much joy and hope out of the writing process. I struggle to keep writing. The ideas dry up. I suddenly never have time. I throw away drafts after several days of work. I’d rather sit around and play video games.I still can’t say anything, because I know I’m not a genius. If I was Patrick Rothfuss the beauty of my words would speak for themselves. I’m not so good that they can’t ignore me, and I never will be.Bring Forth The AIsThis post is a lot more negative than I typically endorse. I do have some dark hatreds in my heart, and I’ll spend most of my life keeping them locked in the dungeon of my soul where they belong, cuz ain’t nobody need to have that in their daily life. But sometimes it’s good to take out those ugly monsters and let everyone see them. Partly because it’s cathartic. Partly because everyone has these monsters and it’s nice to be able to see that none of us is alone in this. There isn’t something uniquely wrong with me for having them, it doesn’t make me an ugly person if everyone else has them too, which I can be assured of if sometimes they are let out and paraded around in an Unholy Anti-Confession. And it makes me appreciate those people more for being pleasant almost all the time and protecting their loved ones from the faces of those abominations.I will never get the awards I wanted to shove in my Dad’s face.5 I would probably never have won them regardless. But now I don’t have the extended social world of sci fi literature. I don’t have a shared mythology and shared dreams with a group of peers. I don’t have the exciting shared topic of what’s the latest good stories, what’s the beautiful new thing that was created, what’s the gossip about what happened at the big convention? I was enwrapped in a culture of shared worlds, shared history, shared heroes, shared context. That world was taken over by people who couldn’t stand to have me interact with them. I don’t have the grand conversation of speculative fiction to swim in, and to add my little part to, anymore. I haven’t had it for many years. And I am still bitter about it.In the year of our lord 2026 the “writing” that AI can do is so very, very bad. It produces the sort of drek that makes the worst Sad Puppies slop look inspired by comparison. It is almost worse than the works of Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki. I would almost rather read O2 Arena again rather than read an AI piece. Almost.And that thought… that produces a slim glimmer of joy. Any award that would shortlist O2 Arena is an award that isn’t evaluating the quality of the fiction. At that point, it has no defense against AI-written submissions.6 Every award that is taken in by an AI-written work is one that should be taken in by AI-written works. Its humiliation is directly due to its abandonment of virtue. Nothing is more richly deserved.So yes, I do delight when these awards are given out to AI-written content. When it’s publicly demonstrated that no one there reads the submissions for their artistic content. They read them for the political allegiances and demographic characteristics of their artists… when they read them at all. Good, let there be many more. I hope they choke on it.1There’s always debate in the community as to whether it’s the Nebula or the Hugo, though for most the Hugo was slightly more desired.2disclaimer: it was not fine3I’d been reading all the Hugo nominees for a while at this point, and my idealism is a little scuffed. Every year there is a nominee in the mix that has no chance of winning because it is plainly bad. It’s there for reasons other than the quality of the work. eg: Mira Grant is extremely personable and fun and has a lot of friends and fans on weight of personality (I hung out with her a few times at cons and can confirm she’s extremely cool and you’d have to be crazy not to like her). Some works are chosen for reasons we looked away from, but joked about privately. In my circle for years whenever we reviewed a really good book we’d joke “Not bad, but it was no Throne of the Crescent Moon.” But I’m happy that this doesn’t happen too much, and the voters always skip past these and give the award to something that’s actually good.4and I’ve read (most of) Lucifer’s Hammer!5For the record, I don’t want to shove them in his face anymore. I respect the hell out of him, and I think he’s great. I would like to make him proud though. An award would help with that, but not a Hugo Award anymore. I’d be embarrassed to win a Hugo in their current state.6Except for Pangram, but hilariously they often refuse to use Pangram because grifters claim that it’s racist.🐾Eneasz BrodskiHPMOR audio book - hpmorpodcast.com. The Bayesian Conspiracy. SF/F stories & novel. DeathIsBad.substack.com. Lover of humans.More ArticlesJoin 2,197 followers9:16 PM · Nov 15, 2026·1,078Views6
@EneaszWrites
@EneaszWrites
Article cover image
Article cover image

I’m Glad that Lit Awards are Going to AI

It’s 2015 in the main auditorium of WorldCon. Outside the raging forest fires of the Pacific Northwest have turned the sky into a red Mordor haze. The air filters of the convention center are in overdrive as the winner of tonight’s seventh Hugo Award is about to be announced. Every breath holds for one of Science Fiction Fandom’s greatest moments of reckoning.

“The award for Best Related Work goes to…

A cheer rocks the room. My voice is among them, elated. My date is silent. Then she turns her face into my shoulder and cries softly. I’m confused by her reaction, she was just as upset by the Sad Puppies vandalization as all the rest of us.

“It was all just so pointless,” she said later. “There was no good outcome. No matter what happened, we all lost.”

In 2015 the Hugo Awards, once among the most prestigious awards in Speculative Fiction1, had been hijacked by a coordinated group with a grudge. They’d packed the ballot with their picks (most of them quite bad). Some categories didn’t have a single nominee that hadn’t been forced on by them. After discussion the fan community converged on “it would be better to vote for No Award over any of these pretenders” as the way to deal with this. But with nearly 6000 ballots cast it was impossible to know if the word had gotten out to everyone, and if everyone was on board. Some people thought it would be better to choose among the options given than leave the award unawarded that year.

The first six awards given out in the first six categories that night all had at least one nominee that hadn’t been placed there by the Sad Puppies group. Each award was given to a non-Sad-Puppy nominee. The award for Best Related Work was the first one that didn’t have a single non-Puppy nominee to vote for. It was the test to see if our community was willing to shut out the vandals, or let them have what they wanted. When the words “No Award” rang out the floodgates of relief burst. We may not have an award this year, but at least the bastards wouldn’t have their scalp.

I had been writing about this for months in my old blog. I’d read and reviewed all the novels, short stories, and novelettes that year. I’d previously been quoted by the head instigator of the Sad Puppies group. I’d been quoted in File770, the SF community gossip magazine. I cared a lot about these awards. I put significant effort into participating in them and going to the conventions where they were awarded. I was very defensive of efforts to hurt them. This was my community. Don’t come for my friends.

That was over a decade ago. Well before AI. Recently “The Serpent in the Grove” won the Commonwealth Short Story Prize despite being entirely written by AI. This was not an AI prize, and there was a scandal. “Where Water Works” won the first Almadía Ventosa-Arrufat International Short Novel Prize and was also written by AI. The top award from the Caine Prize went to a work primarily written by AI.

This sort of degradation of literature awards would have angered me ten years ago. Perhaps broken my heart a bit, though I probably wouldn’t admit it. For such blatant slop to pollute something I cared about would’ve killed me. Now I smile every time I see it. Now I want it to keep happening, more and more, until the stink of it chokes out the very Heavens. I’m not proud of this, but I don’t apologize for it. It can only happen to those who deserve it.

“Mother is the name for God on the lips and hearts of all children”

Let me caveat my next point — I greatly admire my father. Maybe I idolize him. He’s an incredible man who took major risks to smuggle his family out of an authoritarian hellhole (communist Poland) and bring them to a foreign country to make a new life. I owe him so much. Also, he was a man with faults like any other, he was making it up as he went along just like any of us, and he had an infant son literally two decades younger than I am right now.

I don’t think he knew that I didn’t have many friends growing up. That was fine2 because I had books. I had a thousand worlds full of the most fantastic places and exciting people. The world around me could suck to a fair degree and I’d just slip into a better world whenever I wanted. My father didn’t have this luxury. He was navigating a world without plot armor, trying to shield me from the worst effects of growing up poor. He didn’t have time to read for pleasure. That’s what kids do, not adults.

As I grew older my love of fiction only intensified. Rather than outgrowing fiction, my tastes became more complex and (dare I say) refined. But the books still had space ships or swashbucklers on the covers. The older I got the more disdainful he became. He asked me once what I spent all my time reading, and I showed him, somewhat proudly, one of the more interesting books I was into.

“Bajki,” he said, the Polish word for children’s fairytales. He did the thing with his voice that I hated, that he’d been doing since soon after I hit puberty, which said “it’s not even worth my time to engage with you.” He asked what I was doing with these child’s stories. I told him I was going to write. I would make something like this. He let his contempt, his disappointment that this was what his son was aspiring to, show openly.

They say spite is the best motivator. My dad didn’t know about the Hugo or Nebula awards. He didn’t know there was an entire world of prestigious science fiction read by Serious People who use it to think and discourse. I knew that if I told him about it he’d dismiss them too, wouldn’t even bother looking into what was being done in speculative fiction to interrogate the world and our place within existence as fallen humans. There was no argument that a fourteen-year-old reading SF could make that he would listen to. But I did know that if I grew up and I came home with an award, or better yet, if I flew him out to the awards ceremony and made him sit there and watch as respected professionals celebrated and awarded me personally with a trophy and a title that would follow me for the rest of my life, he would be forced to say that I was right. I wanted to win the most prestigious award I could so I could rub it in his smug, stupid face. To show I was respected and deserved his respect as well. Maybe even his admiration.

Why We Write

I don’t start writing until my 30s. Writing doesn’t really pay money, with a handful of extremely notable exceptions. People do not write for money. They write because they love to write, and they are fed by the recognition of their peers. To a first approximation it’s correct to say that authors are motivated by prestige rather than money.

By the time I started writing I’d happily established a toehold in the SF Lit world. I’m in a reading group with fellow local authors who enjoy my takes. I’m in a writers group that includes currently professional authors, has Hugo award winners as alumni, and they are impressed with many of my efforts. I helped run the Literary Track of Denver Comic Con, I had dinner with award winners. I have a group of other hopeful up-comers I’m tight with.

The literary scene has always been pretty leftist. The scifi lit scene is several degrees more leftist than that. SF lit had always prided itself on being ahead of the curve on civil rights, religious tolerance, sexual freedom, women’s lib, gay rights, etc. The scene leaned hard into wokism from the first moments it shrieked itself into existence. Which I thought was good because I was also quite left. If one award nominee slot every year went to advocacy that was fine.3 Maybe even good.

In February of 2015 my first short story was published in Asimov’s magazine. (It was later shortlisted for the 2015 Sidewise Award). That same month K. Tempest Bradford (established editor and thought leader) pushed for everyone to stop reading white men for a year.

The official article in TIME magazine is toned down. I was in the audience when she argued for this during a panel discussion at the convention where the Hugo Awards are given out. The argument was quite direct when she spoke freely. My community erupted into discourse not about if this was an acceptable thing to propose, but about how much one should eliminate white men from the SF community. Should we stop reading them for a year, or only a few weeks? Is it OK to read those who are pre-vetted by trusted editors? Can one save the works of favorite authors to read after the embargo? Maybe we should just not read any by default, but if a piece is known to be really good and it happens to be by a white man it’s OK to read it? Didn’t white men deserve this? Couldn’t they take one measly year of no readers? We all know this won’t happen anyway, haha, so what does it say about someone if they feel threatened by it?

The fact is, white men were still being published, and read, and respected in the community. So saying “I feel this would hurt me” would be an acknowledgement that one believes that their work isn’t good enough to stand on its own. Every year some new white men get their first publishing contract in the SF world, despite being white men. Every now and then they’ll have a hit, just like anyone else. If you can’t get published, if you never make it big, well, you obviously just didn’t have the talent needed to make it. Happens to 99% of people who try. There is no way to say “this is fucked up” without being seen as another no-talent white male blaming his problems on minorities and women. All you can do is keep your head down, keep writing with everything you have, and trust that the crazies will be ignored and you’ll be treated fairly. Everyone is basically good.

We rally to rebuff the Sad Puppies as a united community, and it feels good.

I Get The Hint

I keep writing. I get published in Analog magazine as well, and several anthologies, and win a Writers of the Future award. But it’s getting harder to be in this community. More and more works that are celebrated seem bad. It’s not random either, it’s not just very personable authors getting love from their fans/friends, as the Sad Puppies had complained about — now the badness is strongly correlated with activism. After a few years the only men left in the major awards are those who’ve led woke charges.

My favorite author, N.K. Jemisin, who I hope to some day write half as well as, weighs in strongly in favor of my demographic being removed from SF lit. This really hurts. I had idolized her.

I notice a lot of men authors are adopting They/Them pronouns. Eventually even the “ally” men are removed. The book club I was in reads the Hugo Nominated novels, short stories, and novelettes every year. More and more in the later years I was reading straight racist/sexist diatribes against me, which were being praised by my peers. I’m told you can’t be racist against white men. What, they can’t take it? In the years 2019-2021 no white men appear in the best novel short lists at all (in 2022 Andy Weir breaks this with Project Hail Mary. That is the level of success needed to be considered for a Hugo then.)

I realize I haven’t enjoyed most of what I’ve been reading for years.

The final blow comes in 2020. It’s the second year of the awards lockout. “A Memory Called Empire” wins the Hugo. When I first reviewed it I said

“there is nothing exceptional about this. It’s…. fine. It’s fine. But it’s not good. It’s certainly not genre-defining or among the best things published that year. […]I know there’s at least one Hugo nominated novel that I just don’t get every year, but I don’t think anyone is doing Martine a favor by pretending they think her novel is a Hugo contender. I feel bad that this happened.”

Upon its winning I wrote

I can no longer say anything is “Hugo material” or not, because my judgements of quality do not mesh with the audience of the Hugos. […] I gotta go looking for a community that is more like me

Later that same year “The City We Became” is published. By N.K. Jemisin, the author that just a few years ago wrote one of the best works I’ve read. Her new novel is one of the most racist things I’ve ever read4.

every white person in this story is a monsterit is explicitly their whiteness that makes them monstrous, and makes them want to destroy and exploit all that is good in the world.one can tell when a new antagonist or ally is being introduced as soon as their skin color is describedhairstyles that are popular among young white men are called literal signifiers of evil - it’s presented as bitterly ironic that now such a signifier exists in real life when before it was just the sign of campy script writers.The one attempt to portray a white person in a “sympathetic” light focuses on a mentally handicapped white woman … Nonetheless, she ultimately gives in to her hateful white natureStaten Island is ejected from what is the True New York City and replaced with a borough that has the correct racial demographics for a “good” city.

It’s nominated for a Hugo.

And I finally get the hint. The SF Lit world has been telling me very plainly and very loudly for years that they don’t want me. I can write all I want and I will never know if my words are good or not, because they won’t be read regardless.

I know a few people who write purely for themselves, who don’t even publish what they write. I am not one of them. I don’t want to shout into the void. I want to be seen. To know that no one will read me drains so much joy and hope out of the writing process. I struggle to keep writing. The ideas dry up. I suddenly never have time. I throw away drafts after several days of work. I’d rather sit around and play video games.

I still can’t say anything, because I know I’m not a genius. If I was Patrick Rothfuss the beauty of my words would speak for themselves. I’m not so good that they can’t ignore me, and I never will be.

Bring Forth The AIs

This post is a lot more negative than I typically endorse. I do have some dark hatreds in my heart, and I’ll spend most of my life keeping them locked in the dungeon of my soul where they belong, cuz ain’t nobody need to have that in their daily life. But sometimes it’s good to take out those ugly monsters and let everyone see them. Partly because it’s cathartic. Partly because everyone has these monsters and it’s nice to be able to see that none of us is alone in this. There isn’t something uniquely wrong with me for having them, it doesn’t make me an ugly person if everyone else has them too, which I can be assured of if sometimes they are let out and paraded around in an Unholy Anti-Confession. And it makes me appreciate those people more for being pleasant almost all the time and protecting their loved ones from the faces of those abominations.

I will never get the awards I wanted to shove in my Dad’s face.5 I would probably never have won them regardless. But now I don’t have the extended social world of sci fi literature. I don’t have a shared mythology and shared dreams with a group of peers. I don’t have the exciting shared topic of what’s the latest good stories, what’s the beautiful new thing that was created, what’s the gossip about what happened at the big convention? I was enwrapped in a culture of shared worlds, shared history, shared heroes, shared context. That world was taken over by people who couldn’t stand to have me interact with them. I don’t have the grand conversation of speculative fiction to swim in, and to add my little part to, anymore. I haven’t had it for many years. And I am still bitter about it.

In the year of our lord 2026 the “writing” that AI can do is so very, very bad. It produces the sort of drek that makes the worst Sad Puppies slop look inspired by comparison. It is almost worse than the works of Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki. I would almost rather read O2 Arena again rather than read an AI piece. Almost.

And that thought… that produces a slim glimmer of joy. Any award that would shortlist O2 Arena is an award that isn’t evaluating the quality of the fiction. At that point, it has no defense against AI-written submissions.6 Every award that is taken in by an AI-written work is one that should be taken in by AI-written works. Its humiliation is directly due to its abandonment of virtue. Nothing is more richly deserved.

So yes, I do delight when these awards are given out to AI-written content. When it’s publicly demonstrated that no one there reads the submissions for their artistic content. They read them for the political allegiances and demographic characteristics of their artists… when they read them at all. Good, let there be many more. I hope they choke on it.

There’s always debate in the community as to whether it’s the Nebula or the Hugo, though for most the Hugo was slightly more desired.

disclaimer: it was not fine

I’d been reading all the Hugo nominees for a while at this point, and my idealism is a little scuffed. Every year there is a nominee in the mix that has no chance of winning because it is plainly bad. It’s there for reasons other than the quality of the work. eg: Mira Grant is extremely personable and fun and has a lot of friends and fans on weight of personality (I hung out with her a few times at cons and can confirm she’s extremely cool and you’d have to be crazy not to like her). Some works are chosen for reasons we looked away from, but joked about privately. In my circle for years whenever we reviewed a really good book we’d joke “Not bad, but it was no Throne of the Crescent Moon.” But I’m happy that this doesn’t happen too much, and the voters always skip past these and give the award to something that’s actually good.

and I’ve read (most of) Lucifer’s Hammer!

For the record, I don’t want to shove them in his face anymore. I respect the hell out of him, and I think he’s great. I would like to make him proud though. An award would help with that, but not a Hugo Award anymore. I’d be embarrassed to win a Hugo in their current state.

Except for Pangram, but hilariously they often refuse to use Pangram because grifters claim that it’s racist.

@EneaszWrites
@EneaszWrites
  • Municipal Orrery@MunicipleOrrery9hIt's rough to see people you like taken over by naked bigotry. I hope you didn't lose too many friends to it.
@MunicipleOrrery
@MunicipleOrrery
  • Querculus@seneca_minimus11hSad Puppies was a reaction to the ideological takeover of the Hugos. By insisting on No Award, the Hugos declared: "We no longer listen to the community. We belong to the ideology." That's why no one cares about the Hugos anymore.1
@seneca_minimus
@seneca_minimus
  • Ivy is Beautiful and Talented@IvyAstrix9hwow bro might want to look into that seething rage issue
@IvyAstrix
@IvyAstrix

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by HN AI
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗