China Consumers Association: Many Problems with Online Clothing Shopping, Platforms Must Truly Bear Responsibility
IT之家 November 16 news, according to a CCTV News report today, in recent years, online clothing shopping has become an important consumption method for the public. But at the same time, consumer disputes such as false advertising, substandard quality, difficulty in returns and exchanges, and closed stores losing contact continue to occur at a high rate, seriously infringing on consumers' lawful rights and interests and damaging the healthy consumption environment of the online clothing market. According to statistics, in the first three quarters of this year, the national consumers association smart 315 platform received 26,338 complaints about online clothing.
The China Consumers Association stated that e-commerce platform operators, as the hub connecting supply and demand, must not merely act as a "harvester" of traffic, but should become the "gatekeepers" of rules.
Regarding prominent problems in online clothing shopping, the China Consumers Association's views are as follows:
- Platforms should require merchants to truthfully advertise in accordance with the law and protect consumers' right to know. At present, the problem of false advertising in the online clothing market is prominent. Some merchants on platforms mislead consumers through beauty filters and retouching, AI-generated images, false parameter labeling, and exaggerated fabric texture, and the actual clothing differs greatly from the livestream room and product detail page in color, fabric, thickness, and workmanship. Some merchants pass off inferior goods as superior, and some down jackets, knitwear, and other apparel falsely report down content and wool content. Some merchants also disguise second-hand clothing, sample garments, and defective tail goods as brand-new genuine products for sale, seriously infringing on consumers' right to know and right to fair trade.
E-commerce operators have an obligation to disclose information. Platforms should identify and supervise the business conduct of merchants on the platform, strictly handle and tightly control business practices such as adulteration, passing fake goods off as genuine, and passing inferior goods off as superior, strengthen attention to and sorting of consumer reviews, and handle situations involving false advertising or suspected fraud by merchants on the platform in accordance with regulations, giving consumers a truthful environment for decision-making reference. If a platform clearly knows or should know that a merchant is using the platform to infringe on consumers' lawful rights and interests and fails to take necessary measures, it should, in accordance with Article 44 of the Consumer Rights Protection Law of the People's Republic of China, bear joint and several liability with the merchant.
- Platforms should strengthen constraints on livestream e-commerce operators and prevent behavior that deceives or misleads consumers. In online clothing shopping, from "filtered livestreams" concealing fabric defects, to using recorded videos to disguise real-time interaction, to hosts' false rhetoric of "lowest price on the entire internet" and "clearance flash sale," livestream rooms stage one "visual scam" after another. Some merchants also use rhetorical traps and scenario simulation, exploit the consumption habits and characteristics of different groups of online clothing consumers to make improper promises and create fake reviews, inducing consumers to make impulsive orders and seriously harming consumers' lawful rights and interests.
Livestream e-commerce platforms should strengthen management of livestream room operators, livestream marketers, and livestream marketer service agencies, control behavior such as false advertising, fake reviews, and improper promises, strengthen technical patrols, and resolutely take disciplinary measures against violating accounts.
- Platforms should require merchants on the platform to eliminate arbitrary clauses and protect consumers' right to seven-day no-reason returns. Article 3 of the Interim Measures for the Seven-Day No-Reason Return of Goods Purchased Online stipulates that "online goods sellers shall perform the seven-day no-reason return obligation in accordance with the law." Handling complaints has revealed that some clothing merchants on platforms privately add arbitrary clauses such as "no return after unpacking," "no return after trying on," "no return for 'one-of-a-kind items,'" and "no return for 'tail goods,'" and arbitrarily expand the scope of goods excluded from seven-day no-reason returns.
The seven-day no-reason return is a special right of online shoppers. To protect the rights and interests of online shoppers, the law specifically grants consumers a seven-day "cooling-off period," during which consumers may return goods without reason. For goods to which seven-day no-reason returns do not apply, the Consumer Rights Protection Law of the People's Republic of China clearly stipulates that only goods customized by consumers, fresh and perishable goods, digital goods such as audio-visual products and computer software downloaded online or unpacked by consumers, and delivered newspapers and periodicals may be exceptions.
Article 7 of the Interim Measures for the Seven-Day No-Reason Return of Goods Purchased Online stipulates that the following goods may, after confirmation by consumers at the time of purchase, not be subject to the seven-day no-reason return provisions:
- (1) Goods that easily affect personal safety or life and health after unpacking, or goods that easily cause quality changes after unpacking.
- (2) Goods whose value depreciates significantly once activated or tried out.
- (3) Goods nearing the shelf life and defective goods that have been expressly indicated at the time of sale. Apart from the above goods, merchants arbitrarily expanding the scope of non-returnable goods violates legal provisions.
For acts of setting unfair standard clauses on their own, arbitrarily expanding the scope of goods not subject to seven-day no-reason returns, and restricting consumers' statutory right to return goods, platforms should take effective measures to stop them.
- Platforms should require merchants on the platform to truly bear quality guarantee responsibility and must not arbitrarily restrict consumers' after-sales rights such as returns and exchanges. Online clothing, especially some low-priced clothing, frequently has quality problems such as rough workmanship, messy threads, poor fabrics, easy fading, and easy deformation. When consumers request replacement or return, some merchants on platforms often refuse to bear the replacement and return obligation on the grounds that "the seven-day no-reason return time limit has passed."
The right to seven-day no-reason returns is completely different from the consumer's right to return, replace, and repair when goods have quality problems. Merchants have an obligation to guarantee product quality. Where goods have quality problems, operators shall bear obligations such as return, replacement, and repair in accordance with the law; where consumers return, replace, or repair goods, merchants shall bear necessary expenses such as transportation. In practice, some merchants on platforms deliberately confuse seven-day no-reason returns with product quality guarantee responsibility, refusing on the grounds of exceeding seven days to perform their statutory responsibilities for return, replacement, and repair and to bear shipping costs. In this regard, platforms should strengthen management, urge merchants on the platform to truly bear statutory obligations, and protect consumers' lawful rights and interests.
- Platforms should require merchants on the platform to promptly and properly handle complaints, and if they lose contact and abscond, the platform must bear advance compensation responsibility in accordance with the law. In real life, some platforms disregard consumer rights and interests, and when consumer disputes arise, pass responsibility back and forth with merchants on the platform, causing consumers to spend a great deal of time without solving the problem and making rights protection costs high. In particular, some merchants on platforms close their stores and lose contact after receiving payment; consumers ask the platform for compensation, but the platform refuses to bear responsibility on the grounds of insufficient deposit.
The E-Commerce Law of the People's Republic of China stipulates that e-commerce operators have an obligation to promptly handle complaints and reports, and platforms should actively assist consumers in safeguarding their lawful rights and interests. The Consumer Rights Protection Law of the People's Republic of China stipulates that where an online trading platform provider cannot provide the true name, address, and valid contact information of the seller or service provider, consumers may also demand compensation from the online trading platform provider; if a merchant closes its store and absconds, and the platform cannot provide consumers with the merchant's true name, address, and valid contact information, the platform has an obligation to pay compensation in advance. A platform's refusal to bear compensation responsibility on the grounds of insufficient deposit is an attempt to evade legal liability, and consumers have the right to require it to bear responsibility in accordance with the law.
The China Consumers Association believes that the key reason there are many problems in the field of online clothing shopping is that operator responsibilities are not implemented. Platforms are not a lawless place; for the platform economy to develop, lawful operation is the first priority. Platform enterprises, as the main beneficiaries of creating platforms and attracting traffic for profit, must govern according to the law, act effectively, truly bear their own responsibilities, strengthen constraints and management of merchants on the platform, and truly create a good consumption environment for the broad masses of consumers.

Related Articles
- High-priced rentals, arbitrary deductions, hidden locks: China Consumers Association exposes consumer traps in mobile phone rentals
- Goods not matching descriptions, after-sales delays and buck-passing: China Consumers Association issues blind box consumption reminder
- China Consumers Association releases 2025 complaint hotspots: car 4S store closures making promises unfulfillable, difficulty in refunds and changes on travel platforms, and others on the list
- China Consumers Association reminder: industrial raw materials contain high formaldehyde, handmade toys require vigilance
- China Consumers Association speaks out on civil aviation "paid seat selection": it should not become an "industry convention"
- China Consumers Association releases "Double 11" consumption reminder: rationally identify "third-party review" information