New York City Bans "Big Data Price Gouging": Companies Using Surveillance Algorithms for Differential Pricing Face Fines of Up to $1,000
IT之家, November 16 — The New York City Council on November 12 local time passed a bill restricting algorithmic personalized pricing, prohibiting companies from using consumers' personal data and algorithms to charge different prices to different consumers purchasing the same goods or services.
The bill was proposed by New York City Council Speaker 朱莉 · 梅宁 (Julie Menin), aiming to restrict companies from implementing so-called "Surveillance Pricing" by tracking information such as consumer behavior, location, and purchase records.

According to information published by the New York City Council, the bill is numbered Introduction 891-A and requires companies not to use algorithms to analyze consumers' personal data and set different prices for the same goods or services based on that analysis. The bill applies to the five boroughs of New York City, and violating companies may face civil penalties of up to $1,000 per violation (IT之家 note: approximately 6,690 RMB at current exchange rates).
The New York City Council stated that surveillance pricing typically uses algorithms to analyze consumers' shopping behavior, geographic location, personal characteristics, and historical purchase records to determine how much a consumer is willing to pay for a certain good or service, and then adjusts the quote accordingly. Because this process is usually completed in the background, consumers may not be aware that the prices they see have already been influenced by their personal data.
In an announcement released on November 12, the New York City Council cited several related investigation cases. Among them, an investigation into a major fresh food delivery platform found that the platform had conducted algorithmic pricing experiments, with price differences for some products reaching up to 23% for different consumers.
Another investigation found that a television sold by a certain retailer was priced at $499.99 before consumers entered the store parking lot, and then the price rose to $599.99. In addition, a behavioral economist who once worked at a major ride-hailing company also disclosed that related apps may use a user's low phone battery level as a reference factor for adjusting ride fares, taking advantage of users' urgency to get home to raise prices.
New York City Council Speaker Menin stated that companies using algorithms and personal data to charge different prices to different consumers purchasing the same goods violates the principle of fair dealing and may also increase the cost-of-living pressure on residents.
According to the text of the bill, the New York City Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) will be responsible for investigating related complaints and has the authority to impose civil penalties of up to $1,000 on violating companies. Violations targeting different consumers or different transactions can be counted separately, meaning that if a company implements personalized pricing for a large number of consumers, the final fines it faces may increase further.
The bill also preserves certain normal business promotional activities, including membership rewards, student discounts, veteran discounts, seasonal promotions, coupons, and buy-one-get-one-free offers. Companies may offer specific discounts based on consumers voluntarily joining membership programs, publicly disclosed discount eligibility, or qualifying historical purchase records, but may not arbitrarily combine other personal data with such information to set differentiated baseline prices targeting individuals.
In addition, the bill stipulates that companies need to establish corresponding information disclosure procedures so that consumers can apply to learn what personal data companies considered when setting specific prices and how such data affected the prices.
It should be noted that the bill has currently been passed by the New York City Council but has not yet officially taken effect. According to the New York City Council's legislative record, the bill is currently at the stage of being submitted to the mayor for signature, and the official effective time will be one year after it becomes law.
For some small businesses committing violations for the first time, the bill also sets up a correction mechanism. Eligible companies, after receiving notice from the competent authority, can submit proof of rectification within 30 days and refund the relevant amounts obtained due to the violation to affected consumers, in order to avoid entering subsequent penalty procedures.
- "Sony Recruiting PlayStation Senior Director to Oversee PS Store 'Smart Pricing'"
- "Game Discounts Differ Across Accounts, Sony PSN Store Again Accused of 'Price Gouging'"
- "Prices Vary by Person: Sony PlayStation Is Testing Dynamic Pricing, With Up to 17.6% Price Difference for the Same Game"
Related Articles
- Algorithmic Prices Must Be Disclosed to Consumers, New York State Legislates Against "Big Data Price Gouging"
- State Council Office: Urge Online Travel Platforms and Tourism Operators to Strengthen Personal Information Protection, and Not to Infringe on Tourists' Rights Through "Big Data Price Gouging" and Other Practices
- Adjustments Made to Address "Big Data Price Gouging" and Other Issues, Draft Amendment to the Price Law Open for Public Comment
- Beijing: Centralized Governance of Issues Such as the Use of Algorithms to Implement Big Data "Price Gouging"
- Young People Begin Reverse-Domesticating Big Data Price Gouging: Repeatedly Commenting That Airfares Are Too Expensive Can Cut the Price in Half
- Four Departments: Deeply Rectify "Information Cocoon" Issues, Strictly Prohibit the Use of Algorithms to Implement Big Data "Price Gouging"