Former Nintendo Employee: The Legend of Zelda Was in Serious Trouble Before Breath of the Wild, and the Series Can't Be Confined to a Single Playstyle Long-Term
IT之家 November 16 news — Former Nintendo employees 克里斯塔 Yang (Krysta Yang) and Kit 埃利斯 (Kit Ellis) discussed on a podcast episode on November 13 the reasons behind The Legend of Zelda series' shift from traditional gameplay to open-world design.
According to the account, before The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild was released, the Zelda series was facing serious market difficulties: its core player base was steadily shrinking, growth in new players was weak, and audience interest and sales for multiple titles were trending downward. The two believe Nintendo needed to make major adjustments to the series' gameplay at the time rather than continue using the traditional template.

Some players believe that when Nintendo abandoned traditional Zelda gameplay, the series was still at its peak popularity, and therefore hope the development team will bring back titles centered on traditional dungeons and linear progression. 克里斯塔 Yang said this claim does not match her experience at the time.
She recalled that the series had already fallen into serious trouble at that point, with game sales performing poorly. 埃利斯 said he had participated in player focus group surveys, and the feedback received at the time showed that the series' core fan base was shrinking and the games could not attract new players.
埃利斯 also revealed that Nintendo internally holds detailed data on each game, and the data showed that as new titles were released, player interest continued to decline and the audience grew smaller and smaller. He believes the development team had to take more drastic measures at the time.
The titles the two mentioned include The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess and The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword. Although the latter received relatively high praise from the media, its strong guidance design and traditional gameplay framework also sparked player discussion.

Looking at sales data, there is indeed a clear gap between the traditional titles and the new open-world entries. According to data previously released by Nintendo, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild has cumulative sales of 34.28 million units on the Switch, with the Wii U version also contributing sales; The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom has cumulative sales of 22.9 million units on the Switch. By comparison, The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword on the Wii sold approximately 3.5 million units.
Nintendo has also previously compared the series' sales performance across different console generations in its financial materials. Materials published by the company in 2023 show that The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom significantly expanded the series' sales scale during the Switch generation.
- "The Legend of Zelda Producer 青沼英二: Not Laying Off Staff Is the Key to Nintendo's Success"
Related Articles
- Master Quest clues found in The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake files, possibly to be released as paid DLC
- The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake tops UK physical game sales chart for 2026, launch sales exceed Breath of the Wild
- The Legend of Zelda Producer 青沼英二: Not Laying Off Staff Is the Key to Nintendo's Success
- Nintendo's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time Remake launches on Switch 2 today: HK$449 in Hong Kong region
- Nintendo's The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake review embargo lifts: Metacritic average of 96, the highest-rated game this year
- 3699 yuan, Nintendo's The Legend of Zelda 40th Anniversary Edition Switch 2 goes on sale today