Newshot

Ask HN: Stripe closed us after one $1,500 invoice and never asked for evidence

Original text(via Hacker News)
Ask HN: Stripe closed us after one $1,500 invoice and never asked for evidence
84 points by snirgbs 3 hours ago │ hide │ past │ favorite │ 26 comments
We're a small business that sells pre-booked appointments with homeowners to local contractors, billed per appointment that actually happens. Our first client agreed to this on a recorded call and saved his card through a $1 Stripe payment link, which we planned to use for billing later. That $1 payment went through. A few weeks later we invoiced him $1,500 for 3 completed appointments and charged the saved card. Stripe blocked the payment. Two days after that the account was closed with this wording: payments "don't appear to have been authorized by the customer." What happened next: - We appealed through the Dashboard with an appeal letter, our company documents and the invoice. It was rejected the next day as an "unacceptable level of risk." - Support told us our "business model presents a level of risk we're unable to support" and that the decision is final. - After a Stripe employee escalated it internally, we got a short email saying Stripe still won't accept payments for our business. In all of this, nobody asked us for the call recording, our messages with the client, or a confirmation from the client himself. As far as we know, he never disputed anything, and he has told us he is paying by bank transfer outside Stripe. I'm not saying our setup is perfect. It's a new account, the first real charge was large compared to the $1 test, and billing a saved card later is probably what looked wrong. If there's something specific we should fix, I'll fix it. What I'm asking: 1. Is there anyone at Stripe who can look at this with the evidence, including getting the client on a call? 2. For people who've been through this: how would you structure per-appointment billing so it doesn't look unauthorized (an invoice with a link each time, an email confirmation before each charge, something else)? I can share the account details, the call recording and the messages with anyone from Stripe who wants to look. Thanks for reading.

Our first client agreed to this on a recorded call and saved his card through a $1 Stripe payment link, which we planned to use for billing later. That $1 payment went through.

A few weeks later we invoiced him $1,500 for 3 completed appointments and charged the saved card. Stripe blocked the payment. Two days after that the account was closed with this wording: payments "don't appear to have been authorized by the customer."

What happened next:

  • We appealed through the Dashboard with an appeal letter, our company documents and the invoice. It was rejected the next day as an "unacceptable level of risk."
  • Support told us our "business model presents a level of risk we're unable to support" and that the decision is final.
  • After a Stripe employee escalated it internally, we got a short email saying Stripe still won't accept payments for our business.

In all of this, nobody asked us for the call recording, our messages with the client, or a confirmation from the client himself. As far as we know, he never disputed anything, and he has told us he is paying by bank transfer outside Stripe.

I'm not saying our setup is perfect. It's a new account, the first real charge was large compared to the $1 test, and billing a saved card later is probably what looked wrong. If there's something specific we should fix, I'll fix it.

What I'm asking:

  1. Is there anyone at Stripe who can look at this with the evidence, including getting the client on a call?
  1. For people who've been through this: how would you structure per-appointment billing so it doesn't look unauthorized (an invoice with a link each time, an email confirmation before each charge, something else)?

I can share the account details, the call recording and the messages with anyone from Stripe who wants to look. Thanks for reading.

breue 1 hour ago │ next [–] I had stripe fleece me for 4.5k - tried to complain about them on HN - they nerfed the post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50398646 The sad part is I was one of their first customers - I helped onboard over a 70 clients for them over the years. And my top project generated them $1.6m in pure fees revenue. I even tried emailing Patrick and John - they don't care one bit. Its sad - they used to have a soul - became a ruthless/soulless company. Sorry you are dealing with this... replybreue 1 hour ago │ next [–] I had stripe fleece me for 4.5k - tried to complain about them on HN - they nerfed the post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50398646 The sad part is I was one of their first customers - I helped onboard over a 70 clients for them over the years. And my top project generated them $1.6m in pure fees revenue. I even tried emailing Patrick and John - they don't care one bit. Its sad - they used to have a soul - became a ruthless/soulless company. Sorry you are dealing with this... reply
breue 1 hour ago │ next [–] I had stripe fleece me for 4.5k - tried to complain about them on HN - they nerfed the post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50398646 The sad part is I was one of their first customers - I helped onboard over a 70 clients for them over the years. And my top project generated them $1.6m in pure fees revenue. I even tried emailing Patrick and John - they don't care one bit. Its sad - they used to have a soul - became a ruthless/soulless company. Sorry you are dealing with this... reply
aleqs 3 minutes ago │ parent │ next [–] Are you still using stripe today, or have you found something else? replyaleqs 3 minutes ago │ parent │ next [–] Are you still using stripe today, or have you found something else? reply
aleqs 3 minutes ago │ parent │ next [–] Are you still using stripe today, or have you found something else? reply
The_President 16 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Loading their dashboard now takes as long as brewing an 11 oz k-cup coffee. replyThe_President 16 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Loading their dashboard now takes as long as brewing an 11 oz k-cup coffee. reply
The_President 16 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Loading their dashboard now takes as long as brewing an 11 oz k-cup coffee. reply
weird-eye-issue 24 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] So you allowed people to do card testing on your platform and never recognized it was happening? You have to keep on top of things like that especially if using Stripe Connect where users can withdraw money since you are facilitating theft and money laundering > there was very little negligence on our side Lol > they nerfed the post Nobody nerfed the post. It just isn't interesting since it's your fault. Lesson learned, hopefully! replyweird-eye-issue 24 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] So you allowed people to do card testing on your platform and never recognized it was happening? You have to keep on top of things like that especially if using Stripe Connect where users can withdraw money since you are facilitating theft and money laundering > there was very little negligence on our side Lol > they nerfed the post Nobody nerfed the post. It just isn't interesting since it's your fault. Lesson learned, hopefully! reply
weird-eye-issue 24 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] So you allowed people to do card testing on your platform and never recognized it was happening? You have to keep on top of things like that especially if using Stripe Connect where users can withdraw money since you are facilitating theft and money laundering > there was very little negligence on our side Lol > they nerfed the post Nobody nerfed the post. It just isn't interesting since it's your fault. Lesson learned, hopefully! reply
aleqs 1 minute ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] It's very interesting actually, and there is no evidence that they 'allowed card testing on your platform'. Not to mention it would be stripe that would be the main facilitator of card testing in this scenario, so it would be on them to detect and alert the user if that was happening. replyaleqs 1 minute ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] It's very interesting actually, and there is no evidence that they 'allowed card testing on your platform'. Not to mention it would be stripe that would be the main facilitator of card testing in this scenario, so it would be on them to detect and alert the user if that was happening. reply
aleqs 1 minute ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] It's very interesting actually, and there is no evidence that they 'allowed card testing on your platform'. Not to mention it would be stripe that would be the main facilitator of card testing in this scenario, so it would be on them to detect and alert the user if that was happening. reply
matheusmoreira 8 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ prev │ next [–] So the corporation doesn't care about a guy who generated 1.6 million dollars in fees and onboarded additional clients? Even when they post about their problem publicly on HN? I suppose it's hopeless for the rest of us. replymatheusmoreira 8 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ prev │ next [–] So the corporation doesn't care about a guy who generated 1.6 million dollars in fees and onboarded additional clients? Even when they post about their problem publicly on HN? I suppose it's hopeless for the rest of us. reply
matheusmoreira 8 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ prev │ next [–] So the corporation doesn't care about a guy who generated 1.6 million dollars in fees and onboarded additional clients? Even when they post about their problem publicly on HN? I suppose it's hopeless for the rest of us. reply
weird-eye-issue 1 minute ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] He misused their platform by failing to do proper verification of marketplace users and transactions and allowed criminals to extract several thousand dollars from victims of credit card theft. He's the one at fault here and his unverified claims about fees sounds like it's from a different project anyways so what exactly do you expect support to do? Roll out the red carpet and help him out with these fees related to the funds he helped launder? If he was negligent and didn't do the proper verifications of the buyers and sellers on his platform then he shouldn't have set it up in the first place. It's basic common sense and if he's really used Stripe so much he would know that. Instead of immediately blaming Stripe why don't you ask him if he followed all of the best practices for using Stripe Connect replyweird-eye-issue 1 minute ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] He misused their platform by failing to do proper verification of marketplace users and transactions and allowed criminals to extract several thousand dollars from victims of credit card theft. He's the one at fault here and his unverified claims about fees sounds like it's from a different project anyways so what exactly do you expect support to do? Roll out the red carpet and help him out with these fees related to the funds he helped launder? If he was negligent and didn't do the proper verifications of the buyers and sellers on his platform then he shouldn't have set it up in the first place. It's basic common sense and if he's really used Stripe so much he would know that. Instead of immediately blaming Stripe why don't you ask him if he followed all of the best practices for using Stripe Connect reply
weird-eye-issue 1 minute ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] He misused their platform by failing to do proper verification of marketplace users and transactions and allowed criminals to extract several thousand dollars from victims of credit card theft. He's the one at fault here and his unverified claims about fees sounds like it's from a different project anyways so what exactly do you expect support to do? Roll out the red carpet and help him out with these fees related to the funds he helped launder? If he was negligent and didn't do the proper verifications of the buyers and sellers on his platform then he shouldn't have set it up in the first place. It's basic common sense and if he's really used Stripe so much he would know that. Instead of immediately blaming Stripe why don't you ask him if he followed all of the best practices for using Stripe Connect reply
codingdave 1 hour ago │ prev │ next [–] I have no knowledge specific to Stripe or your case, but do I know that the pattern you just described - a small 1 dollar payment followed by a large payment - is the exact pattern that criminals use to test stolen credit cards numbers. My bank will automatically reject anything following that pattern, put a hold on my card, and call me to confirm whether or not I have my card. So yeah, if your business model calls for pattern matching with how stolen cards are used, that could very well be unacceptable risk to Stripe. replycodingdave 1 hour ago │ prev │ next [–] I have no knowledge specific to Stripe or your case, but do I know that the pattern you just described - a small 1 dollar payment followed by a large payment - is the exact pattern that criminals use to test stolen credit cards numbers. My bank will automatically reject anything following that pattern, put a hold on my card, and call me to confirm whether or not I have my card. So yeah, if your business model calls for pattern matching with how stolen cards are used, that could very well be unacceptable risk to Stripe. reply
codingdave 1 hour ago │ prev │ next [–] I have no knowledge specific to Stripe or your case, but do I know that the pattern you just described - a small 1 dollar payment followed by a large payment - is the exact pattern that criminals use to test stolen credit cards numbers. My bank will automatically reject anything following that pattern, put a hold on my card, and call me to confirm whether or not I have my card. So yeah, if your business model calls for pattern matching with how stolen cards are used, that could very well be unacceptable risk to Stripe. reply
matheusmoreira 5 minutes ago │ parent │ next [–] I don't get it... I've had plenty of actual corporations test my credit card in that exact manner. PayPal for example literally turned this into second factor authentication mechanism: they charged me some random amount and demanded to know the value they charged me. Apparently this is proof that I have access to the associated bank account. replymatheusmoreira 5 minutes ago │ parent │ next [–] I don't get it... I've had plenty of actual corporations test my credit card in that exact manner. PayPal for example literally turned this into second factor authentication mechanism: they charged me some random amount and demanded to know the value they charged me. Apparently this is proof that I have access to the associated bank account. reply
matheusmoreira 5 minutes ago │ parent │ next [–] I don't get it... I've had plenty of actual corporations test my credit card in that exact manner. PayPal for example literally turned this into second factor authentication mechanism: they charged me some random amount and demanded to know the value they charged me. Apparently this is proof that I have access to the associated bank account. reply
pstuart 50 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Out of idle curiosity, how might such a business such as the OP's be able to arrange payments to use Stripe without getting shut down? replypstuart 50 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Out of idle curiosity, how might such a business such as the OP's be able to arrange payments to use Stripe without getting shut down? reply
pstuart 50 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Out of idle curiosity, how might such a business such as the OP's be able to arrange payments to use Stripe without getting shut down? reply
alwa 15 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] Be upfront about the plan when you do the initial authorization. Stripe lets you signal a “set up a card on file” intent for this purpose, which doesn’t involve actually charging it $1. IIRC it either provides or expects you to provide user-facing language like “you’re putting this card on file with this merchant, you know they’re going to charge it in the future according to their policies, right?” https://docs.stripe.com/payments/cards/save-and-reuse https://docs.stripe.com/payments/save-and-reuse Or, like, send a fresh invoice for the $1500. But charging a sale for $1 as a way to make sure the card is good is not the way. It sure used to be the way in the low-fi days of physical terminals, but not today. Either way I imagine you might earn more benefit-of-the-doubt once you’ve established a track record of smooth transactions. replyalwa 15 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] Be upfront about the plan when you do the initial authorization. Stripe lets you signal a “set up a card on file” intent for this purpose, which doesn’t involve actually charging it $1. IIRC it either provides or expects you to provide user-facing language like “you’re putting this card on file with this merchant, you know they’re going to charge it in the future according to their policies, right?” https://docs.stripe.com/payments/cards/save-and-reuse https://docs.stripe.com/payments/save-and-reuse Or, like, send a fresh invoice for the $1500. But charging a sale for $1 as a way to make sure the card is good is not the way. It sure used to be the way in the low-fi days of physical terminals, but not today. Either way I imagine you might earn more benefit-of-the-doubt once you’ve established a track record of smooth transactions. reply
alwa 15 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] Be upfront about the plan when you do the initial authorization. Stripe lets you signal a “set up a card on file” intent for this purpose, which doesn’t involve actually charging it $1. IIRC it either provides or expects you to provide user-facing language like “you’re putting this card on file with this merchant, you know they’re going to charge it in the future according to their policies, right?” https://docs.stripe.com/payments/cards/save-and-reuse https://docs.stripe.com/payments/save-and-reuse Or, like, send a fresh invoice for the $1500. But charging a sale for $1 as a way to make sure the card is good is not the way. It sure used to be the way in the low-fi days of physical terminals, but not today. Either way I imagine you might earn more benefit-of-the-doubt once you’ve established a track record of smooth transactions. reply
rtpg 25 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Don't charge $1 first? API-wise you can attach a card to a customer without charging it. Maybe the $1500 thing still fails anyways but it won't look as much like fraud? Or, y'know, just send the $1500 invoice after the fact and have that involve the client put in the card details there as a first shot. You _should_ (IIRC) be able to charge + capture the card in one go. replyrtpg 25 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Don't charge $1 first? API-wise you can attach a card to a customer without charging it. Maybe the $1500 thing still fails anyways but it won't look as much like fraud? Or, y'know, just send the $1500 invoice after the fact and have that involve the client put in the card details there as a first shot. You _should_ (IIRC) be able to charge + capture the card in one go. reply
rtpg 25 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Don't charge $1 first? API-wise you can attach a card to a customer without charging it. Maybe the $1500 thing still fails anyways but it won't look as much like fraud? Or, y'know, just send the $1500 invoice after the fact and have that involve the client put in the card details there as a first shot. You _should_ (IIRC) be able to charge + capture the card in one go. reply
ShinyLeftPad 26 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Criminals? I think AWS (or something similarly large) used to hold a dollar to make sure the card works, it's a pattern that is used replyShinyLeftPad 26 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Criminals? I think AWS (or something similarly large) used to hold a dollar to make sure the card works, it's a pattern that is used reply
ShinyLeftPad 26 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] Criminals? I think AWS (or something similarly large) used to hold a dollar to make sure the card works, it's a pattern that is used reply
anonymous908213 5 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] Amazon does a small precharge on all of my grocery deliveries. This pattern is universal. I suppose it's easier for "engineers" to come up with pants-on-head idiotic solutions and special-case exemptions for large partners than it is to use their noggin and implement any kind of system capable of actually working. replyanonymous908213 5 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] Amazon does a small precharge on all of my grocery deliveries. This pattern is universal. I suppose it's easier for "engineers" to come up with pants-on-head idiotic solutions and special-case exemptions for large partners than it is to use their noggin and implement any kind of system capable of actually working. reply
anonymous908213 5 minutes ago │ root │ parent │ next [–] Amazon does a small precharge on all of my grocery deliveries. This pattern is universal. I suppose it's easier for "engineers" to come up with pants-on-head idiotic solutions and special-case exemptions for large partners than it is to use their noggin and implement any kind of system capable of actually working. reply
anonymous908213 41 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] It's also the pattern that millions of businesses use. It's like pattern matching against transactions on days that end in "y". You certainly will capture all fraudulent transactions that way, but... replyanonymous908213 41 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] It's also the pattern that millions of businesses use. It's like pattern matching against transactions on days that end in "y". You certainly will capture all fraudulent transactions that way, but... reply
anonymous908213 41 minutes ago │ parent │ prev │ next [–] It's also the pattern that millions of businesses use. It's like pattern matching against transactions on days that end in "y". You certainly will capture all fraudulent transactions that way, but... reply
didgeoridoo 1 hour ago │ prev │ next [–] Yeah unfortunately this charge pattern could not have looked MORE like merchant fraud. The right approach would have been to use https://docs.stripe.com/payments/setup-intents and set it for off-session usage. You still might have gotten a payment hold on the first transaction until someone in risk could take a peek at your site to make sure you had all the right disclosures in place, but you probably would have kept the account. replydidgeoridoo 1 hour ago │ prev │ next [–] Yeah unfortunately this charge pattern could not have looked MORE like merchant fraud. The right approach would have been to use https://docs.stripe.com/payments/setup-intents and set it for off-session usage. You still might have gotten a payment hold on the first transaction until someone in risk could take a peek at your site to make sure you had all the right disclosures in place, but you probably would have kept the account. reply

The sad part is I was one of their first customers - I helped onboard over a 70 clients for them over the years.

And my top project generated them $1.6m in pure fees revenue. I even tried emailing Patrick and John - they don't care one bit. Its sad - they used to have a soul - became a ruthless/soulless company.

Sorry you are dealing with this...

there was very little negligence on our side
they nerfed the post

Nobody nerfed the post. It just isn't interesting since it's your fault. Lesson learned, hopefully!

I suppose it's hopeless for the rest of us.

So yeah, if your business model calls for pattern matching with how stolen cards are used, that could very well be unacceptable risk to Stripe.

PayPal for example literally turned this into second factor authentication mechanism: they charged me some random amount and demanded to know the value they charged me. Apparently this is proof that I have access to the associated bank account.

IIRC it either provides or expects you to provide user-facing language like “you’re putting this card on file with this merchant, you know they’re going to charge it in the future according to their policies, right?”

https://docs.stripe.com/payments/cards/save-and-reuse

https://docs.stripe.com/payments/save-and-reuse

Or, like, send a fresh invoice for the $1500.

But charging a sale for $1 as a way to make sure the card is good is not the way. It sure used to be the way in the low-fi days of physical terminals, but not today.

Either way I imagine you might earn more benefit-of-the-doubt once you’ve established a track record of smooth transactions.

Maybe the $1500 thing still fails anyways but it won't look as much like fraud?

Or, y'know, just send the $1500 invoice after the fact and have that involve the client put in the card details there as a first shot. You _should_ (IIRC) be able to charge + capture the card in one go.

You still might have gotten a payment hold on the first transaction until someone in risk could take a peek at your site to make sure you had all the right disclosures in place, but you probably would have kept the account.

Have you tried simply sending invoices via Stripe? Works for me, without a hitch. And it's pretty flexible; you can do a lot to modify terms, add notes, send email notices to multiple parties, etc.

If that won't work, there are payment processors who specialize in "high risk" accounts. Paykings come to mind. I've actually heard good things.

I imagine that's not a dissimilar transaction pattern to how escort services and similar businesses might try to use Stripe.

Obviously there's no easy way for Stripe to tell if you are actually doing what you say you are doing.

In addition, based on my having a more than passing familiarity with laws regulating construction contracting [1], I would not be surprised if there are jurisdictions where your service is in violation of the laws and regulations governing construction contracting.

Even if it is legal where you are, there's no obvious way for Stripe to know that's the only place you operate. And if you only operate locally, you can use a local bank to process credit cards...assuming you meet normal criteria -- if you don't meet normal criteria, it's reasonable for Stripe to decline your credit card processing business.

So my advice, if you want to operate locally work with a local banker, a local lawyer, and a local insurance agent. These might not scale, but scaling is only a problem once you have a going business. Good luck.

[1] The laws regarding construction contracting are an "is" I am not arguing that those laws are/aren't an "ought."

The CEO or CTO of Stripe will be with you shortly.

The text above was extracted automatically from the source page and may miss images, tables or code blocks. The original is authoritative.

Published by Hacker News
This site only summarises and aggregates; copyright stays with the original author. Headlines and summaries follow the source — where they differ, the original wins.
Read the original ↗